Playing in the NFL can make a player rich, but it doesn't guarantee he'll stay that way when his career is over. Consider this: 75 percent of former NFL players are broke.
That’s right. Within five years after an NFL player has retired from the game (assuming he played three years or more), chances are he’s lost all the money he made in his career. The amazing part about this number is that it also applies to players who played 10 years or more. To compound the problem, about 75 percent of NFL players are also divorced, according to a recent story in the New York Times.
This is an issue I’ve written about in the past. As an agent, it frustrates me that this number hasn’t changed. You’d think that the legions of new players would learn from the mistakes of those who preceded them. They haven’t. You’d think that the NFL Players Association financial advisory watchdog registration plan would weed out bad advisers. It hasn’t. You’d think that the millions spent on player development resources by the NFL and team owners would help. It hasn’t. You’d think that the army of seasoned agents in place today could surround their clients with good financial people. They’re haven’t.
There are a lot of reasons why the 75-percent figure is not going away any time soon. Here are five:
1. Large agencies and financial firms help create bad habits. When firms are competing to sign first-round picks, one of the biggest tools in their arsenal is the “line of credit” or “up-front loan.” It can also be disguised as a ”marketing advance.” They range in size from $50,000 to $500,000. Between the draftee’s last college game and the day he signs his first contract, he has cash to burn with little or no accountability. Thus, bad habit No. 1 begins: Spend money before you make it.
Solution: Put a cap of $75,000 on loans from agents and financial advisers registered with the NFLPA and create sizable penalties for breaking these rules. But I doubt this will ever happen.
APBoxer Evander Holyfield made millions and bought this home, which is in foreclosure.
2. Taking care of the family is a noble thing, but have a plan. Many draftees can’t wait to take care of their parents, extended family and even their friends. The problem is that once you turn on the faucet, it’s very difficult to turn it off. It’s like a drug, and you’re giving it away for free. Remember, the brother or aunt who is two months behind in their car payment will always be behind. If you help them out, it’s only a short-term fix to a long-term problem. Also, don’t finance other people’s dreams, especially if they don’t have the skill set or experience to run a business. Their dream will turn into your nightmare.
Solution: Build your savings for three years and allocate a portion to income-producing securities like low-risk tax-free bonds. Use the “income only” to help out immediate family members, thus holding on to your principles. Also, put yourself on a tight allowance and let it be known that you don’t have instant access to your money. Make the financial adviser the bad guy. If you want to help out your parents, pay down and or pay off their mortgage and get your name on the title. I actually had a client do this, and his parents started taking out home equity loans and ran their debt right back up to the number he paid off. Paying off a mortgage will increase their cash flow. One of the hardest things for young players to do is say no to family.
3. I’ve seen about 70 percent of my clients make loans to friends and families. I’ve also seen very few ever get paid back. Once again, it’s hard for these young men to say no to friends and family.
Solution: Have zero tolerance for loans and don’t ever co-sign for a loan.
4. There’s a perception among the poor and underprivileged that material things such as cars, houses and jewelry represent wealth. Unfortunately, people with these things only have money, but people with investments are the ones who have wealth. I always ask my clients, ”Do you want to be rich or do you want to be wealthy?” Boring investments will make you wealthy. Having material things may make you look and feel rich, but they’re depreciating assets that eventually make you poorer.
Solution: There really isn’t a solution other than education. The need to have material things, such as four cars or $500,000 worth of jewelry, is a learned behavior that can be promoted by a rap video of a flashy investment adviser.
APTaking a private jet may be nice, but is it really worth it?
5. Easy come, easy go. If there isn’t a watchdog keeping track of daily spending, then the spending will always gradually increase. Players have a lot of time on their hands in the offseason, and their wives who don’t work, raise kids or volunteer may have even more free time. Idle time often results in spending sprees on home remodels, clothing, vacations, toys and other things that don’t have appreciating values. Simply put, young couples live beyond their means because they don’t exercise discipline. Flying first class, renting private jets and blowing $50,000 in Vegas a few times a year adds up quickly.
Solution: Get rid of the yes people in your life and surround yourself with professionals who aren’t afraid to call you out on your spending habits. Have a strict budget and don’t let yourself exceed it under any circumstances. Many agents and financial advisers don’t have the guts or interest to interfere in the financial affairs of their players because they’re scared they’ll be fired. The ones who do are the ones who really care.
The NFL offers one of the best retirement plans in all of sports. However, a lot of work still needs to be done to educate young men on their fiduciary health and responsibilities. My theory and experience has been that bad habits can be changed, but it’s difficult to do when you’re surrounded by a peer group that’s in the same boat.
Unfortunately, I think I may be writing about this subject once a year.
Follow me on Twitter: jackbechta
Jack - Great column!!
All the advice you have listed is not only good for athletes, but good for everyone to listen too.
Another great column. I really appreciate the inside look at things with the hard stats to back it up.
2 Thumbs Up!
Best story on this I have ever seen.....the broke former (and current) pro players from all sports litter that landscape like so many discarded pop bottles.
Very well done Jack
Also--use birth control or, better yet, get clipped so you don't end up owing child support. Avoid stupid investments that are easy to start but seem to rarely pay off--like a restaurant or whatever.
Great Column. I agreed with everything you said.
Awesome article, with sobering stats and facts. Plus advice we can all use, when scaled back to our working class lives!
Great column. A lot of people look down on broke athletes as morons, but I don't know many people who could handle huge amounts of money well in their early 20's.
This has got to be a tough issue for ethical agents.
Really enjoyed this column! Well done and very interesting!
I think it is important to note that the 75% number I quote for "broke players" has not been formally quantified by the NFL or the NFLPA. However, i strongly feel that the number is easily over 55% to 60% based on my 23 years of experience in the agent and finance business. furthermore, if you have clicked through to the the NY Times article it's important to read this rebuttle from Joe Browne of the NFL:
Letter to the Sports Editor:
Your story “Taking Vows in a League Blindsided by Divorce” states that “unnamed” polls and studies—combined with “anecdotal evidence”—“suggests” that the divorce rate for NFL players is between 60-80%. If our office had been asked, we would have offered a much different view based on a University of Michigan phone survey in 2008 of 1,040 retired NFL players. That poll found 64.5% of retired players ages 30-49 are still married to their first wife while 52.7% of retirees 50 years or older also are married to their first spouse. These numbers are better than the national average.
Joe Browne, Executive Vice President, NFL
Jack,
You're right on. This applies to young military members as well. I saw far too many spending and not saving during my years in the Service. Developing sound financial habits early will lead to long term financial security. Keep up the good work.
Nice article. Always good to read about this side of football - the side that does no get the coverage.
It must be hard for these young guys who feel like they are the king of the world and untouchable to plan for their future in 10/20/30 years when their earnings power is maximised over a short period of time in their 20's.
Jack:
As someone that works with athletes, I was going to submit an article to you EXACTLY on this topic. Like Holyfield, I saw what happened to Mike Tyson (as his former insurance agent), when he spent tons of cash on a ridiculous house and on a bunch of leeches (his posse) all with their hands out. Forget about what Don King did to him. He needed an education.
I have the solutions these men (and women) need. As you say, it takes a lot to say "no" to someone that had only heard yes his/her whole life.
Just ask the Fridge or Brien Taylor
"don’t finance other people’s dreams" Jack I've seen this quote from you before and I simply don't get it. Every form of investment is financing somebody's dream. There's no way around it.
Who better to invest with than a dreamer?
I have not yet done so; but I'm willing to bet that if I dig into the history of The National Football Post, I'll find somebody funding someone's dream.
Excellent column, Jack!!! I've got a novel idea though, how about requiring that all NFL players have four full years of college again? Maurice Clarett tried and failed, but someone will eventually succeed at getting drafted out of high school, and if you think young 20-somethings are poor with their cash-handling skills, 18 year olds are much, much worse. How about a required college level course on financial management that they must graduate from before they can sign a contract? How about BANNING agent loans entirely? I mean, I know they graduate from college and as such no longer get to live on campus, but they can still live with their parents and be fed pretty cheaply until they DO get the money. You did miss a point, what about the ones who get the loans, and don't make it? 20 years old, an NFL washout, and 300,000 in debt?
Jack: I was in a very similar field and was asked by a high profile NFL player to help with his finances. He was impressed enough to enter our business. Unfortunately his efforts help his contempories was so much in contrast to the active players, my friend dropped out!! My friend was totally dismayed by the fact he could cite countless cases of players in depair and his contacts never felt it would happen to them!
Excellent article. I agreed with everything you .. Thanks
Mark F - I think you are missing Jack's point. Investing money with a trusted and reputable financial adviser is a much different concept than financing a buddy's dream who has absolutely no idea how to run a business.
It's a little cold to say that ALL relatives or friends will always be 2 months behind on car payments, etc. , if they are at any point in their lives. Unexpected things happen: loss of job, loss of health insurance. In general his advice is good, but there are exceptions.
It is almost as if this article fell into our laps! Thank you Jack!
I'm part of a small (3 person) advisory for pros on remaining fulfilled in a meaningful way.
This is not in any way a financial services organization.
We take time evaluating the player and then determine his (always a male - so far) other significant as well as latent interests and carve out a plan to fulfill that third half of their life.
We help the player visualize his life and his goals.
We are very discreet.
AMEN!
Nicely Stated!
| powered by TheSeats.com |
Super Bowl means catering to clients,...
With no salary floor and fewer...
Eliminate the game and give players...
Taking care of business and keeping...
An ‘umbrella’ can provide coverage...
Aug 19, 2009
11:10 AM
Jack - Great column!!
All the advice you have listed is not only good for athletes, but good for everyone to listen too.