NFP Team Pages » Baltimore Ravens | "Where your voice is heard"

RSS

Let's play the realignment game!

Think the NFL has their eight divisions set up correctly? Then get a load of what we have in mind. Joe Fortenbaugh

Print This March 04, 2013, 01:30 PM EST
9 Comments

A report surfaced last week that the National Hockey League is proposing a realignment plan that would see the sport shift from six divisions to four. Before we continue, I want it on the record that I realize how dangerous it is to begin a football column by talking about hockey. 65% of you most likely left the page after reading the words “National Hockey League,” and for that, I apologize. Actually, I don’t apologize. If you’ve already left, you wouldn’t be reading this fake apology anyway.

In between an enthralling Sunday spent doing laundry and shopping for groceries, I began thinking about the possibilities of realignment within the NFL. Not in the sense of whittling the current eight-division format down to six, but in the sense of shifting teams around to see what would happen. The National Football League already has a tremendous product in place, but that didn’t stop me from asking whether there was a way to realign the divisions to make it even better.

Taking geographic proximity, existing rivalries and rivalries that should exist into account, I’ve come up with eight new divisions for your viewing pleasure.

Enjoy.

AFC EAST

Teams: New England Patriots, New York Jets, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles
Nickname: Uncivil War
Longest travel distance prior: Foxborough to Miami at 1,503 miles
Longest travel distance after: Foxborough to Philadelphia at 298 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “Look at this fu@$*^& guy!”

Tom Brady and Eli ManningBrady losses two guaranteed wins against the Bills for two games against his kryptonite.

A thin stream of drool began trickling slowly from my lower lip to my black sweatpants preciously three seconds after putting this idea down on paper. The rabid fan bases of Boston, New York and Philadelphia converge in what would quickly become the most hate-filled and upper deck fight-invested division in all of professional sports. Two key rivalries remain intact, while the Brady-Eli Manning feud no longer has to be put on hiatus in-between Super Bowl get-togethers. This division showcases four northeast organizations who play outdoors, Chip Kelly vs. Bill Belichick and New York vs. New York. Hell, this article started as a goof, but now I’m losing sleep over the possibilities.

AFC NORTH

Teams: Chicago Bears, Cincinnati Bengals, Green Bay Packers, Indianapolis Colts
Nickname: High Cholesterol
Longest travel distance prior: Baltimore to Cincinnati at 523 miles
Longest travel distance after: Cincinnati to Green Bay at 501 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “Nice dome, Colts.”

There’s just no way you can bust up the Green Bay-Chicago rivalry, so we’ll substitute Minnesota and Detroit for a couple of up-and-comers that feature two young quarterbacks who have already combined for three playoff appearances. Had Chicago not collapsed down the stretch last season, this division would feature four playoff teams from the 2012 campaign. Cincinnati says goodbye to the Ravens and Steelers while Indy fans are probably cringing at the thought of replacing Jacksonville with Green Bay. This division offers some of the best tailgating treats of any on the list.

AFC SOUTH

Teams: Jacksonville Jaguars, Miami Dolphins, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Tennessee Titans
Nickname: Cocktails & Dreams
Longest travel distance prior: Indianapolis to Houston at 1,053 miles
Longest travel distance after: Nashville to Miami at 914 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “We still have a team? I was wondering what everybody was doing here.”

Before you scoff, think of the upside this newly created division could have on the attendance levels for professional football in Florida. By dividing the Sunshine State into three sectors of teams in close proximity, the NFL may finally be able to generate some decent rivalries for Jacksonville, Tampa Bay and Miami. Plus, imagine being a fan of one of these teams. You’d actually go into Week 1 thinking your squad has a shot at making the playoffs. The Jaguars would go from 250,000 to 1 to a respectable 100 to 1 to qualify for the postseason, while Miami loyalists would no longer need to worry about the meatheads from New York and Boston coming down to crap on their parade twice a season. The downside to this division is that the league would immediately need to institute a new rule: No sub-.500 team is permitted to play in the postseason.

AFC WEST

Teams: Oakland Raiders, San Diego Chargers, San Francisco 49ers, Seattle Seahawks
Nickname: The Vancouver to Tijuana Highway
Longest travel distance prior: Kansas City to Oakland at 1,800 miles
Longest travel distance after: Seattle to San Diego at 1,256 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “Dude, I’m so baked right now.”

Oakland RaidersNo matter the rivalry, Raiders fans will show up in full battle regalia.

Oakland fans may be pissed to lose the four games a year they currently get against hated rivals Kansas City and Denver, but those people are disgruntled about everything. You could put the beloved U.S. women’s gymnastics team in the Raiders’ division and The Black Hole would still be throwing bottles. The budding feud between Seattle and San Francisco remains in place, while San Diego retains its title as the NFL’s preferred travel destination for fans looking to hit the road once a year. And just think about how much fun it would be to watch the Niners and Raiders butt heads twice a season. The police presence at those showdowns would be so overwhelming that you could probably rob any bank in the Bay Area that day with nothing more than a Super Soaker and a Vespa.

NFC EAST

Teams: Baltimore Ravens, Carolina Panthers, Pittsburgh Steelers, Washington Redskins
Nickname: Mobile, Agile & Argyle
Longest travel distance prior: New York to Dallas at 1,582 miles
Longest travel distance after: Pittsburgh to Charlotte at 448 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: [While waving yellow towel, reminiscing about the days of Ray Lewis or driving America into even more insufferable debt] “Are the Panthers from North or South Carolina?”

RG3 vs. Newton, The Battle of the Beltway and the continuation of Steelers-Ravens. Successfully navigate this gauntlet of kill shots and you’ll be as prepared for the postseason as any team in the business. The premiere quarterback division in football, watch as all four teams bust through the salary cap every offseason looking to upgrade their respective defenses. Spend a minute pondering the possibilities when this division crosses over with the new-look NFC South.

NFC NORTH

Teams: Buffalo Bills, Cleveland Browns, Detroit Lions, Minnesota Vikings
Nickname: Tim Hortons
Longest travel distance prior: Detroit to Minneapolis at 713 miles
Longest travel distance after: Buffalo to Minneapolis at 940 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “Pass me another Molson Ice, eh?”

Buffalo and Cleveland were meant for one another, while Detroit and Minnesota carry their bad blood over to their new digs. Adrian Peterson smiles knowing he could run for 2,500 yards as an amputee and Calvin Johnson prepares to smash all of Jerry Rice’s longstanding receiving records. Browns fans rejoice at the once-ludicrous notion of winning a divisional title, Buffalo fans celebrate the end of Tom Brady’s one-man assault on their franchise. Everybody wins, except for the team that wins this division, as they go on to lose in the wildcard round.

NFC SOUTH

Teams: Atlanta Falcons, Dallas Cowboys, Houston Texans, New Orleans Saints
Nickname: Steers & Beers
Longest travel distance prior: Charlotte to New Orleans at 767 miles
Longest travel distance after: Atlanta to Houston at 793 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: [The exact same thing you hear at every Eagles, Giants and Redskins game currently, no matter the opponent] “Dallas sucks.”

Tony RomoRomo can celebrate knowing he no longer has to deal with the fans from Philly, New York and Washington.

Everybody hates the Cowboys. So football purists can stop complaining about the demise of the current NFC East rivalries because it would take approximately 26 seconds for the fan bases from Atlanta, New Orleans and Houston to pick up where Philly, New York and Washington left off. Four domes, minimal travel and a whole lot of offense. Houston has been in the league since 2002 and still has yet to establish a legitimate rivalry with another NFL franchise. Problem solved. This is the type of division that you could see coming down to the wire each and every season.

NFC WEST

Teams: Arizona Cardinals, Denver Broncos, Kansas City Chiefs, St. Louis Rams
Nickname: Barbeque at Altitude
Longest travel distance prior: St. Louis to Glendale, AZ at 1,475 miles
Longest travel distance after: St. Louis to Glendale, AZ at 1,475 miles
Phrase most often heard at divisional matchups: “Can’t wait to see how we screw up the two-minute drill today.”

Oh-so-close Super Bowl losers Jeff Fisher, John Fox and Andy Reid come together in a division that also includes the impossible-to-realign Arizona Cardinals. Seriously, try this divisional realignment experiment on your own and let me know where Arizona ends up. It’s not easy. The Broncos have a cakewalk to the playoffs as long as Peyton Manning is still around, but how would that be any different from last season? A new rivalry is formed in Missouri and lasts exactly two years until St. Louis relocates to Los Angeles. And just imagine how much Lipitor you would need to consume to combat the effects of a St. Louis-Kansas City tailgate.

Hit me up on Twitter: @JoeFortenbaugh

Comments

Add a Comment
Jason
Mar 05, 2013
07:34 AM

I think the NFL would be better without divisions. With 32 teams and only 16 games per regular season, there's no reason to play the same team twice. Why play certain teams twice per season and other teams once every four years? The team that wins the super bowl is hailed as the champion of the league even though they played fewer than half of the other teams in the league . There would be plenty of good reasons for not having divisions at all, playing all teams equally often and having the playoff tree be based on W-L records league-wide. Another reason is fairness but I won't go into that.

The justifications for having divisions are flawed. Artificially creating rivalries by making two teams play each other often is silly, especially because the same two teams are inhibited from ever playing each other in the most exciting matchup possible, in the super bowl. Divisions prevent more rivalries than they create. NE and NYG are a great rivalry but most likely Manning and Brady will face off only one more time in their careers because they're in different conferences. Same goes for Eli and Peyton. Travel is not a big issue when there are only 16 games. Besides, travel can't be the main reason for divisions because the current divisions are not fully optimized for travel. (e.g. Miami in the AFC East, Dallas in NFC East),



ayitmilkhamah
Mar 05, 2013
09:03 AM

I never liked the way things were aligned in the divisions. But Pittsburgh should be with the Cleveland, Cincy- group not the NFC East in this scenerio. Also why in heck is Dalllas in NFC East now? I guess we could have a lot of opinions on this. I like the idea of no divisions. Split the league East and West with a designated number of playoff spots.

John H
Mar 05, 2013
09:22 PM

I like it, but put the Falcons in with the FL teams, Cardinals in with the Texas teams, and Titans in with Denver, KC, and St. Louis. And while we're at it, since no one likes the Cardinals, move them to Vegas.

John Covello
Mar 14, 2013
06:51 PM

Some with consider this heresy, but there really is no need for 2 seperate conferences -- and I say that as an old dye in the wool AFL fan (back to the Joe Willie Namath days). Best thing would be 2 divisions of 16 teams. Have 2 divisions winners be the only ones guaranteed the #1 and #2 playoff spot with the other 10 going to the teams with the best records. Set up bracket by seeding teams 3-10.

Would have a lot of balance.
East (NE, NYG, NYJ, PHI, BALT, WASH, CAR, ATL, JAX, TB, MIA, BUFF, PITT, CLEV, CINN, DET 9 old AFC, 7 old NFC)

West ( IND, NASH CHI, GB, STL, NO, MINN, KC, DALL, HOU, DEN, ARIZ, SD, SF, OAK, SEA 9 old NFC, 7 old AFC)

Travel & TV scheduling would be much easier 1 p.m starts for East teams, 4 p.m for West, although when IND plays home they would also have to be a 1 pm ET start,

Doubt it would happen but would make the most sense.

BTW, both the NBA and NHL should both go to 2 conferences and eliminate divisions - would just make it easier for the playoffs.

Fenris
Mar 17, 2013
03:29 PM

Quite simply, putting the Jets and Giants in the same division is a terrible idea.

Joe
May 01, 2013
10:38 AM

The NFL definitely needs to realign, however they don't need to keep conferences. Why should the best teams play each other before the Super Bowl? That's why so many Super Bowls are boring. Simply have divisions and then seed all the playoff teams in order of who did the best in the regular season and have a better chance of the best teams playing in the Super Bowl.

vinnie
May 28, 2013
02:17 PM

no, this is how the NFL should realign. NFC EAST-NYG,PHILLY,WASH,CLEVE. NFC NORTH-DET,CHI,GB,MINN. NFC SOUTH-TB,ATL,CAROLINA MOVES TO ST. LOUIS,DALLAS. NFC WEST-SEA,SF,AZ,THE RAMS MOVE BACK TO LOS ANGELES. AFC EAST-BUF,NE,NYJ,BALT. AFC NORTH-PITT,CINCY,INDY,JACKSONVILLE MOVES TO TORONTO. AFC SOUTH-MIA,TENN,NEW ORLEANS,HOUSTON. AFC WEST-KC,DEN,OAK,SD.

rtXC1
Jun 07, 2013
02:35 AM

No! Without expanding this is what we should see:

NFC E-
PHI, WAS, NYG, #Buffalo

AFC E-
PIT, BAL, NYJ, NE

NFC S-
TB, CAR, NO, DAL

AFC S-
MIA, JAX, #ATL, HOU

NFC N-
#CLE, DET, CHI, GB

AFC N-
CIN, Tenn, IND, #Minn

NFC W-
SF, STL, SEA, AZ

AFC W-
OAK, KC, DEN, SD

Notice how each region is represented in both conferences. Insert a permanent cross-over rivalry (NY-NY, SF-OAK, etc) and there you have it!

David Crowe
Sep 24, 2014
03:48 PM

The last realignment was almost perfect except the stupid NFL got its directions screwed up.
3 changes in the AFC
Miami moves to the south
Baltimore moves to the east
Indianapolis moves to the north and has to play some cold games.
One change in the NFC
Carolina and Dallas switch divisions.

Next 1 - 9 of 9 Prev COMMENTS

Add a Comment

* Required - Keep track of your comments Login or Register with NFP
(will not be published)