Some players shouldn’t work out for teams. Here’s why. Jack Bechta
Every year at this time, a group of draft prospects makes a decision not to participate in the NFL Combine drills. For most of them, it sends the wrong message to decision-makers.
When top-rated prospect Ndamukong Suh declared that he’ll be working out in Indy this week, it came as a surprise to some because most top prospects defer their workouts until their college pro days. Suh’s decision to perform is great for both his draft stock and his brand.
For those who opted not to work out, I hope they have good reason and are being advised by competent agents and trainers.
Who shouldn’t work out? Anyone who’s nursing an injury that would affect his performance, especially the 40-yard dash. If a player is uncertain he can perform some or all of the skill tests, he should probably wait until his pro day. The key is to go to Indy with a plan. If the player is not going to perform, he should make that clear, through his agent, to NFL teams and combine organizers prior to attending.
My advice: Do not make a game-time decision at the combine.
In 1998, client Tim Dwight went to the combine with strict instructions not to run his 40 or attempt any drills. He was nursing a severe groin injury from the season that was taking a long time to heal. However, once the reigning Big Ten 100-meter champ arrived, Tim’s adrenaline and competitive juices got the best of him and he decided to run. The result was his worst 40 time ever: 4.63 seconds. Horrible! The projected third-round speedster was taken in the middle of the fourth round.
The conundrum for players like Tim who are tough and don’t make excuses for injuries is that they won’t tell anybody if they’re hurt. So he gets no credit for running when he shouldn’t have. A good 40 time is a must for receivers, DBs and running backs.
Those who are healthy should perform. The combine is a test in which players and trainers already know the answers. Simply performing can make a great first impression.
While at the East-West Shrine Game last month, I ran into Bill Parcells at practice. We began talking about one of my retired O-linemen, former Patriots guard Todd Rucci. In the middle of our conversation, Parcells turned to Cowboys scout Walter Juliff, who was standing next to him, and said, “I fell in love with Rucci at the combine. I didn’t know a thing about him, but when he ran his first 40, that was it for me. I drafted him in the middle of the second round.”
Rucci is a smart guy. When he got to the combine, he was in a monster class of behemoth offensive linemen like Willie Roaf (6-6, 325) and Lincoln Kennedy (6-6½, 335). At 6-5 and 285 pounds, Todd felt small next to those guys. When everyone else was on the turf warming up for the 40, he made it a point to stay far away from them so he couldn’t be measured against their size. He actually went to the sideline, away from the linemen, to stand near the receivers and stretch and warm up when they did – and where, of course, he was the biggest guy. He even recalled Parcells sitting in the second row watching him warm up.
Todd played to his strengths of flexibility and athleticism as much as he could. After missing the first four games of his senior season at Penn State and being snubbed by the postseason all-star games, he easily could have fallen through the cracks. But the combine was an opportunity to make a good impression on the decision-makers and the Big Tuna -- which he did.
Good luck this week to all the draft prospects, especially my five who will be attending, running and performing.
Follow me on Twitter: jackbechta
If my memory serves me correctly, Rucci ran a 5 flat or 5.1. good but nothing spectacular. However, in watching a guy move around and run a 40 NFL people can get a feel of what kind of athltete they are.
If you can get a Cujo late, you can a Rucci early, any time you damn well want.
Jack-
Great article as always. You mention running into Bill Parcells and conversing which makes me wonder are there certain people on the management and decision-making side who are more agent friendly than others? If so, is it more the norm for people in this position to be friendly to agents or do you more often run into the opposite where people are hostile because of previous contracts/bad deals that didn't work in their favor.
Thanks.
As you point out, people who seize that opportunity can make a convincing argument for their selection when pro scouts are there for the big name team mates. Extra value is what usually separates teams in acquiring talent, extra effort is what gets that vlue noticed, good luck in the coming days to all the draft hopefuls.
Today’s high profile NFL Combine...
When it comes to Super Bowl tickets,...
QB took road less traveled, hiring...
Introducing three more rounds...
A GM’s draft choices, hires and...
Feb 22, 2010
09:54 AM
Interesting stories. I know most GMs/coaches will say the eval is mostly complete before the combine. Kevin Colbert actually put a guesstimate on in last year at 90%. Still, given the diff between college and pros and levels of competition these prospects face, I think film work is a bit overvalued. And that the combine and pro days are a means of confirming if what they see on film is legit or if they're just beating up a bunch of future stockboys. Too many scouts fall in love with celluloid. See Jarvis Moss.
Still, I think the case of Rucci is an example of the combine giving too much rise to a player's stock. With the post-season snubs, I'm guessing most had him as a late rounder. In retrospect he was obviously better than that, as he was better than most OL in that class. But there were still good players taken after him. Better players. Will Shields went a round later. Dotson and Compton. And Chris Gray in R5. So while Parcells was probably astute to move him up, seems he moved him up too high.
As mentioned Rucci had frame issues, and had already missed games to injury. Those to me are longevity/durability redflags. Could he hold up against the bigs over time? He did have a short career, as careers go for OL who make it.
And what was it that sold Parcells on Rucci? I can't find his combine results. Was it his performance or was it that Parcells recognized his craftiness?
Was Dotson one of your guys that year too? And who are you repping in this year's class? Is J'Marcus Webb one of the 5?