The headline news of the past week, the Cleveland Browns’ stunning trade of second-year tailback Trent Richardson to the Indianapolis Colts, has been studied and analyzed from just about every angle. There have probably been autopsies—hold the jokes, please, about the Browns burying their chances for respectability in 2013 with the move—in which there was less cutting and probing.
Since I’m not a doctor and don’t play one on TV, I won’t reach for a scalpel in trying to dissect the weird deal. Neither will I attempt to discern the so-called “winner” of the trade, because it’s premature to ascertain the long-term fallout. But even minus a degree in psychology – the closest I’ve come to one is a few low-level courses as an undergraduate and a few more in grad school, none of which earned me better than a “B” grade – I’ll take an amateur stab at trying to read the sentiments of at least one person in the wake of the deal. And watching longtime league coach Norv Turner in taped interviews after Richardson was sent packing, it certainly seemed, at least from his body language, like the Browns’ offensive coordinator wasn’t a guy who pushed exceedingly hard for the tailback’s exit. Instead, it looked as if Turner, a good soldier, loyally toed the party line.
That’s not to suggest that the triumvirate of club president Joe Banner, general manager Michael Lombardi and coach Rob Chudzinski simply pulled the rug out from under the guy who calls the Cleveland plays. Or that Turner, who inherited the former Alabama star when he arrived at the Browns, was a champion of retaining Richardson instead of claiming an additional first-round draft pick in 2014. It’s just that Turner, adroit at the art of the non-answer after three previous stints as an NFL head coach, bobbed and weaved conspicuously when queried about the club’s spin-doctors’ explanations that Richardson wasn’t a “good fit” for the offense.
For sure, Richardson’s statistical track record, admittedly a small sample size (only 17 games), indicated he is not a back with the ability to author the big, game-altering play. His resume included just two rushes of 20 or more yards, none longer than 32 yards, and a per-carry average of just 3.5 yards, only 3.4 yards this season. There are concerns about his ability to play on third down, and he had been relieved of those responsibilities in recent days. But his injuries aside, Richardson appeared to be a player capable of a 20-carry workload. A steady, if admittedly unspectacular, runner. And one might think, given Turner’s history in the league, he could actually use such a guy.
Richardson averaged just 3.5 yards per carry during his 17 starts with the Browns.
In the hours after the trade, long before the dust had settled but typical of the “instant analysis” nature of the New Age Media, an Internet expert applauded the deal, citing Turner’s pedigree as a passing guru. Nothing could be further from the truth. In his previous 22 seasons as either a coordinator (seven years) or a head coach (15 seasons), the popular misconception about Turner is that he always favored putting the ball in the air, sometimes recklessly. But anyone who has spoken to Turner – and the bet here is that a lot of a folks who attempted to instantly dope out the Richardson-to-the-Colts deal have never so much as met him – knows that he wants to run first. Turner may not emanate “tough guy” vibes, because he can be lofty and erudite in his demeanor at times, but he revels in physical football. There have been instances, in fact, when Turner took public umbrage at the notion that he sometimes ignored the run in favor of conjuring up passing-game X’s and O’s.
Just look at the numbers.
When armed with a physical runner in particular, Turner has always espoused a tough ground attack. Thirteen times in his 22 seasons, he enjoyed feature backs who logged over 250 carries in a season; in 10 of those years, his top back went for over 300 attempts. With Emmitt Smith (Dallas), Terry Allen (Washington), Stephen Davis (Redskins), LaDainian Tomlinson (San Diego), Ricky Williams (Miami), Frank Gore (San Francisco), heck, even with Lamont Jordan (Oakland), on his roster, Turner-designed offenses ran the ball often and effectively. Granted, there were occasions because of injuries or lack of a true feature back—when the best he could trot out on a weekly basis was Ricky Ervins, Amos Zereoue, or Mike Tolbert—when Turner didn’t have much with which to work. But when Turner had a stud, workhorse back on the roster, a guy who could pound the ball inside, he usually rode him.
The league has skewed toward the multiple-running back attack, but Turner never really was one to embrace the run-by-committee model.
On a dozen occasions, Turner’s offenses produced 1,200-yard rushers. There were seven occasions he had 1,400-yard backs. Even accounting for the pedestrian backs noted above, guys he was forced to employ in some of those 22 years, Turner’s lead runners averaged 277.2 rushes and 1,167.0 yards. Eight times, his running games finished statistically higher than his passing attacks. Turner running games were among the top 10 almost as many times (nine) as were his passing designs (10). There were even two seasons in which his teams ran the ball more than they threw it, and his 45 percent ratio of run-to-pass plays wasn’t nearly as lopsided when he had a top back who could power the ball.
It’s tough, from afar, to know what went on inside the Cleveland locker room, although the legitimate shock emanating from some Browns’ players after the trade indicated Richardson was a popular teammate. It’s equally difficult to determine what was going on in the collective craniums of Banner, Lombardi and Chudzinski, what they were thinking when one of them picked up the phone Tuesday, dialed up Colts’ general manager Ryan Grigsby (whom had previously worked with Banner in Philadelphia), and initiated the trade. His critics in Philly notwithstanding, Banner, a guy we’ve known for a long time, is savvy. Onetime buddy Lombardi is one of the most astute talent evaluators we’ve known in more than three decades of covering the league. So there was rationale, not just a willy-nilly impulse, in the trade.
“(The trade) was a hard swallow, but it was a swallow we felt we had to make, given where we want to go,” said a mid-level Cleveland staffer on Thursday morning. “It won’t be popular (locally), but sometimes you have to take a step back in order to take two (steps) forward. In the short-term, it might not sell well, and there will be a lot of differences of opinion. But we thought it was right.”
The long-suffering fans of Cleveland probably don’t want to hear this, but the new regime appears to be starting over yet again, and has amassed seven choices in the first four rounds of the 2014 lottery. It was laudable of Banner to declare that it will be difficult for the fans to trust the new football folks until they earn that trust. There is a sense, however, that new ownership and the new football flow-chart simply isn’t interested in leftovers from its predecessors. If it means taking a wrecking ball to the status quo, so be it. If you’re quarterback Brandon Weeden, or some of the other skill-position players on a roster bereft of difference-makers, you might want to rent, not buy. We’re not in a position to agree or disagree with the trade, although, if we were a Colts’ fan, we’d be fairly ecstatic right now. Let’s tell it like is: The swapping of Richardson was all about positioning the Browns for the future, most probably for getting a quarterback.
To hint, even remotely, that the trade was completed in part because Richardson didn’t dovetail well with what the Browns and Turner want to do moving forward seems to smack a bit of being disingenuous.
+AROUND THE LEAGUE
There's a good chance that quarterback Brandon Weeden is playing elsewhere after the 2013 season.
*There seems little doubt that the Browns’ brain trust has already decided that Weeden isn’t the quarterback around whom it will build and that landing the “championship”-caliber quarterback the team covets (a credo that hangs in the team’s draft “war room,” as documented by some area media) is the priority. One that, if you’re a betting man, will be addressed in the first round next April. Almost as notable is the decision by Chudzinski to bypass presumptive primary backup Jason Campbell and start journeyman Brian Hoyer (one career start) this week with Weeden nursing a thumb injury, and to publicly suggest that the 2012 first-rounder isn’t necessarily guaranteed to get his job back when healthy. Still, there are folks in the NFL who think Hoyer, even though he’ll be a placeholder in Cleveland even if he wins the starting job for the remainder of ‘13, has some talent. Some NFL personnel people are still surprised that Bill Belichick (a longtime friend of Lombardi, it should be noted) released Hoyer in 2012, after bringing him to the Patriots as an undrafted free agent in 2009.
“(Belichick) thought he had some talent, was competitive, and had the right make-up,” said one person familiar with Hoyer’s three-year stint in New England. “I always thought he had sort of the Belichick seal of approval, and people would take that into account.”
*With his track record of sending players to the draft during his tenure at Alabama, there seems little doubt about Nick Saban’s ability to produce and prepare players for the NFL. But the trade of Richardson certainly boils up some doubts about Crimson Tide running backs of recent vintage. In the past three seasons, Alabama has had two first-rounders (Richardson and former Heisman Trophy winner Mark Ingram) and a second-round pick (Eddie Lacy). There are legitimate questions about New Orleans’ choice of Ingram, who has only 10 starts in two-plus seasons and has averaged just 3.8 yards, in 2011. Lacy hasn’t gotten off to the fastest start in Green Bay and is dealing with a concussion. And now Richardson has been traded despite having been the third overall pick in 2012. The less-heralded backs who played for Saban and were drafted into the league – Le’Ron Mclain, Glen Coffee and Kenneth Darby – haven’t exactly been world-beaters. Coffee retired after one season in San Francisco. Darby hasn’t played in the NFL since 2010. McClain has had a solid career, now in its seventh year, but principally as a fullback. He registered 902 yards for Baltimore in 2008, but has less than 400 yards total in his other seasons in the league.
“One thing we’ve got to remember is that (Saban) always has great offensive lines, and that helps his backs,” said one area scout. “And, truth be told, with the way Nick uses his backs, he probably rubs some tread off the tires. But, hey, no excuses, we’ve got to do a better job of (evaluating) these guys.”
*A couple weeks ago in the Sunday Blitz, we noted the development of Kansas City third-year linebacker Justin Houston, who now has 7.5 sacks after wreaking havoc against the Philadelphia offense on Thursday night. But another Chiefs’ defender who has stepped up big-time is Dontari Poe, who started all 16 games in 2012 after being the 11th player chosen in that draft, but who was deemed fairly ordinary by those who watched him closely. This year, Poe has dominated interior linemen and, in addition to throttling the inside, has provided that rarest of commodities for a nose tackle: a pass rush. “Great penetration in the (first three) games so far,” said inside linebacker Derrick Johnson, another of the team’s premier defenders. “He’s not just a run guy, someone who holds the middle and allows other guys to make the plays. He’s making plays himself, both (against) the run and the pass.”
Poe had zero sacks in 2012, but has 3.5 already this year, and his inside pressure has been a huge part of a defense that has collected 14 sacks in three outings, after registering just 27 a season ago. The durability and stamina of Poe has been eye-opening. Unlike most 3-4 nose tackles, he stays on the field on passing downs, and has participated in all but eight of the 194 snaps against the Kansas City defense. In fact, he has played all the snaps in each of the last two games. Poe has credited a better diet, and the resultant loss of 20 pounds, for his enhanced production, and that has doubtless been a factor. But the Kansas City coaches, who didn’t know him last year, suggest that he’s using his hands and leverage much better, and that Poe clearly has a better understanding of the game and his role, along with better practice habits.
*On the subject of inside pressure, Buffalo left end Mario Williams, coming off a 4.5-sack performance, credits tackles Kyle Williams and Marcell Dareus for creating the inside heat that has provided him for spacing on the outside. Although he started all 16 games in 2012, Williams is fully healthy again after missing much of the previous season. And Dareus, who has some attributes of a defensive end, can be a monster at times.
“You’ve got to get some (inside) push, and those guys can give it,” Williams said. “You can’t just expect to just run around (the tackle) every time.”
Peyton Manning now has to deal with the loss of his best blocker in LT Ryan Clady.
*Peyton Manning has always done an exemplary job of making his offensive line better than it probably should be. The sum, mostly because of Manning and his quick release and knowledge of the game, was generally better than the individual components. But even for Manning, overcoming the season-ending Lisfranc injury to left tackle Ryan Clady will be a difficult chore. Last year, when the Broncos were trying to negotiate an extension for Clady (which they finally accomplished this spring), a high-ranking Denver executive told us that the team considered Clady “one of the three or four best” left tackles in the league. The three guys he put in the same class were Jason Peters (Philadelphia), Jake Long (then with Miami), and Joe Thomas (Cleveland). And he suggested that Clady, a three-time Pro Bowl blocker, might be the best pure pass protector of the bunch. Nothing against Chris Clark, the veteran journeyman who will replace Clady, but the Broncos probably will have to make some tweaks to their protection scheme to insulate Manning. The good news is that, while the Broncos have favored a three-wide receiver set in the first couple of games, Manning worked a lot with two-tight end looks in Indianapolis. And while emerging young tight end Julius Thomas can’t yet do all the things Dallas Clark once performed for Manning and the Colts, he has some similar qualities that will make him a tough matchup. The long-term good news: Clady is a remarkably quick healer, as he demonstrated in his recovery from a patella tendon injury in 2010, and he should not have complications coming back in 2014.
*Following his team’s 31-24 defeat at Atlanta last week, Rams coach Jeff Fisher lamented the St. Louis defense’s inability to slow a Falcons’ offense that he conceded had become “very one-dimensional” (just 36 rushing yards) because of the early-game loss of starting tailback Steven Jackson to a thigh injury. “It’s disappointing, no question,” Fisher said. “We’ve got to ask ourselves why it happened.”
Another question, one that perhaps the Falcons are asking themselves, is how much longer they can survive without injured wide receiver Roddy White making a contribution. White, nursing a right high ankle sprain sustained in an August 15 preseason game, has played in the first two regular-season contests, but is essentially a decoy and little else. “It’s getting better, but it hurts not to be myself,” White said after the victory over the Rams.
One disgusted St. Louis defender suggested the Falcons “could have put a mannequin out there, and he would have moved better than White, and we still couldn’t shut (Julio) Jones down.” Jones caught 11 passes for a career-best 182 yards, and one has to wonder how potent Atlanta will be when White returns to full health. At the same time, there are some in the league who wonder whether coach Mike Smith – who is somewhat Belichick-like concerning injuries, and has never acknowledged White’s injury, even if the wide receiver has admitted it – might be better off using Harry Douglas. The subject of a Sunday Blitz note last week, Douglas has been impressive in the slot, and played surprisingly well, too, when he’s been aligned outside. How big a decoy has White been?
Jones (left) has had to pick up the slack thanks to White's high ankle sprain.
In two games, he’s been targeted just five times, and caught all five passes, but only for 40 yards. His 8.0-yard average is way below his 14.0-yard mark entering the season. Since the start of the 2009 season, when the NFL began including “targets” in its game wrap-ups, White has been “targeted” fewer than five times in a contest only twice in 64 games before the start of this season. He was a “target” 10 or more times in 40 of the 64 games. So having only five passes thrown to him in two outings is, indeed, a comedown. White, who has reiterated his ankle is improving, is eager to get well. “I’ve never had something like this for such a stretch,” said White, who has averaged 93.8 catches, 1,295.5 yards and 8.2 touchdowns over the last six years. “I’m (anxious) to make up for lost time.”
*There are a lot of reasons the Seattle Seahawks are one of the early favorites to contend for a Super Bowl berth, but one of the overlooked ones might be the work that assistant head coach Tom Cable has done with the offensive line. For sure, the unit has a pair of obvious standouts in left tackle Russell Okung (first round, 2010) and center Max Unger (second round, ’09). But the remaining three starters – left guard Paul McQuistan, right guard J.R. Sweezy and right tackle Breno Giacomini aren’t supposed to be anything special. But Cable has cobbled the group into an excellent, physical unit, in part because of his ability to get the most out of guys who were once pretty much regarded as spare parts. The Seattle offense isn’t hitting yet on all cylinders, and second-year quarterback Russell Wilson hasn’t been especially sharp, but no one questions the toughness of the line.
“He’s really solid,” assessed former Atlanta longtime snapper Todd McClure, who played for Cable with the Falcons in 2006. “He wants technique and he wants toughness, and he’s not going to settle. He makes you better, a lot better.”
That’s been obvious in Cable’s work with the Seattle line. McQuistan is a former third-round pick in Oakland, but started only six games in his first three seasons, and was released by three franchises before signing on with the Seahawks. Sweezy was a seventh-round choice in 2012 who started just three games as a rookie. And Giacomini, a fifth-rounder in Green Bay in 2008, who played in one game his first three seasons, was plucked from the Packers’ practice squad, cut by the Seahawks, then re-signed. Okung and Unger are no-brainers when one asks about the Seattle offensive line. But McQuistan, Giacomini and Sweezy are the no-names who have made the unit one of the best in the league. Good enough that former No. 1 pick James Carpenter couldn’t crack the lineup until Okung suffered a toe injury that will sideline him indefinitely. McQuistan will move out to left tackle and Carpenter will slide in at left guard. Cable should get a lot of credit for cross-training guys but, in larger part, for making something out of some guys who weren’t seen as anything special.
*An update on a note from a week ago: Through the Thursday night game, the league is now averaging 131.7 offensive snaps per game, which would be a record if the pace continued. While the presence of the Eagles’ Chip Kelly and his fast-break offense has something to do with it, 13 teams averaged more snaps than did Philly in the first two weeks, and opponents actually ran more plays than the Eagles in each of the past two games. . . . Speaking of Kelly, a few people in the league employed the same term, “too cute,” in describing his failed “swinging gate” try for a two-point conversion on Thursday evening. . . . Beyond the “fast-break football,” the other most conspicuous trend in the early weeks of the season is the number of injuries. Through Wednesday morning, there were 153 players on season-ending injured reserve. And that’s not counting short-term I.R., with players designated for return, or PUP, or any of the league’s various other reserve lists. For all of the many explanations offered, the competition committee, which carefully studies such things, can’t come up with one clear factor for the increase. . . . With Richardson gone and Weeden probably going at the end of the season, another member of the Browns’ 2012 draft class who might have a tough time sticking in Cleveland is second-year right tackle Mitchell Schwartz. A third-round pick, the former Cal standout started every game in 2012 as a rookie, and both games this year. But he’s struggled and might not be in the long-term plans. . . . There was plenty of head-scratching when Chicago hired Marc Trestman as the replacement for the well-respected Lovie Smith. But Trestman seems to be getting more out of quarterback Jay Cutler than Smith and his staff did. That bodes well for the Bears, whose offense has been better than expected. And it’s certainly good for Cutler, who is in the final season of his contract. . . . While the trend is away from coaching “retreads,” people in the know insist Smith will be at or near the top of short lists for teams seeking a replacement in 2014. . . . Defensive end/linebacker Cameron Wake gets a lot of the credit for a Miami pass rush that has generated nine sacks in two games, and the former CFL star (37.5 sacks the previous three seasons) is deserving of that kind of attention. But the improved Dolphins have a league-high seven defenders with at least a half-sack each. And the feeding frenzy on opposition quarterbacks is getting contagious, Miami players say.
+BY THE NUMBERS
*The Lions face the Redskins on Sunday at FedEx Field and, remarkably, Detroit has never won at Washington, no matter the stadium. Counting three playoff losses, including a 41-10 defeat in the 1991 NFC championship game, the Lions are 0-21 in road games against the Redskins. The average margin of defeat in those 21 matchups is 17.1 points. Eleven of the games were determined by 20 points or more and only six by seven points or less. The Redskins have won four of the last seven regular-season games in the series by at least 21 points.
MAR 07 Joel Corry
Front offices and agents of soon-to-be free agents can begin discussions this weekend.
MAR 04 Jerry Angelo
At some point, even the best partnerships in the NFL will begin to dissolve.
MAR 04 Jeff Fedotin
Amidst swirling rumors, Colts would serve as perfect team for embattled tackle.