RSS

Tavern talk: McDaniels manages the game well

Play calling at end of half can be important. Michael Lombardi

Bookmark and Share Print This Send This November 10, 2009, 04:59 PM EST
19 Comments

Pittsburgh was very impressive Monday night in its win over the Broncos, but also impressive were Josh McDaniels’ comments after the game when he was questioned about his end-of-the-half game management. Here’s a link to the video, and if game management interests you, please watch it.

McDaniels is asked about his strategy to make sure he ends the half without giving the ball back to the Steelers. So his first objective is to run time off the clock and prevent them from making a play — not get into his two-minute. If he can reduce the time, he knows all he will need to score is around 1 minute, 30 seconds in the half, so there’s no sense in running the two-minute drill. The reporter never really understood, but this is another example of why McDaniels will be so successful. He gets the objective at the end of the half, which so many in the NFL fail to understand.

Josh McDanielsAPJosh McDaniels is an impressive game manager for a rookie head coach.

Here’s an example of what not to do -- and since Eagles coach Andy Reid holds the title of worst game manager in the NFL, is there really a need to spend time breaking down his mistakes from a week ago? I said on the Bill Simmons podcast that Cowboys coach Wade Phillips must have hijacked Reid’s headset and made every call for the Eagles that would benefit the Cowboys the most. How else can you explain Reid’s actions? I know he’s won over 100 NFL games, but that’s what makes his game-day actions even more bizarre. There’s good Andy and there’s bad Andy, and bad Andy always has the red flag. Someone needs to get that flag away from him. His judgment at critical times in critical games makes every Eagles fan doubt his ability to lead this team to a Super Bowl. And even diehard Reid fans know this is an area of great concern.

Back to end-of-the-half strategies -- first in New England with the Dolphins failing to make the right choices.

S.Gostkowski kicks 70 yards from NE 30 to end zone, Touchback.

PENALTY on NE-J.Sanders, Offside on Free Kick, 5 yards, enforced at NE 30 - No Play.

S.Gostkowski kicks 75 yards from NE 25 to end zone, Touchback.

Miami Dolphins at 2:45

1-10-MIA 20 (2:45) C.Henne pass short left to B.Hartline to MIA 38 for 18 yards (B.McGowan). P9

Timeout #2 by NE at 02:18.

NEW ENGLAND ONLY HAS ONE MORE TIMEOUT LEFT SO IT MUST RUN THE BALL AT SOME POINT TO FORCE THE PATS TO USE IT. THEIR GOAL IS TO SCORE, BUT THEIR SECOND GOAL IS TO MAKE SURE IF THEY PUNT THE BALL BACK, THE PATS ARE OUT OF TIMEOUTS.

1-10-MIA 38 (2:18) R.Brown up the middle to MIA 36 for -2 yards (T.Banta-Cain).

Two-Minute Warning

2-12-MIA 36 (2:00) MIA 6-White now at QB. (Shotgun) P.White pass incomplete short right to G.Camarillo [T.Banta-Cain].

Pat WhiteAPDolphins QB Pat White

BAD CALL HERE. HAD THE FINS RUN THE BALL, THE PATRIOTS WOULD HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO STOP THE CLOCK UNLESS THEY USED THEIR TIMEOUT — SO A RUN WOULD BENEFIT THE FINS MORE THAN ANY OTHER CALL. BUT THE INCOMPLETE PASS GIVES THE PATS AN EXTRA TIMEOUT.

3-12-MIA 36 (1:55) MIA 7-Henne now at QB. (Shotgun) C.Henne pass incomplete short right to D.Bess.

WITH THE PASS CALL THE DOWN BEFORE, THIS PLAY SHOULD BE A RUN SINCE THE FINS ARE NOT A GOOD THIRD-AND-LONG TEAM. BUT THIS INCOMPLETE MEANS THE PATS HAD FIVE TIMEOUTS FOR THE HALF.

4-12-MIA 36 (1:50) B.Fields punts 50 yards to NE 14, Center-J.Denney, fair catch by W.Welker.

New England Patriots at 1:43

THIS IS BAD. THEY GET THE BALL BACK WITH MORE THAN ENOUGH TIME AND ONE TIMEOUT. VERY POOR GAME MANAGEMENT BY MIAMI.

1-10-NE 14 (1:43) (Shotgun) T.Brady pass short right to K.Faulk to NE 21 for 7 yards (J.Taylor, G.Wilson).

2-3-NE 21 (1:19) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete short middle to S.Aiken.

PENALTY on MIA-V.Davis, Defensive Pass Interference, 13 yards, enforced at NE 21 - No Play. X14

1-10-NE 34 (1:14) (Shotgun) T.Brady pass short right to W.Welker to NE 43 for 9 yards (N.Jones) [C.Wake].

2-1-NE 43 (:56) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete deep left to R.Moss.

3-1-NE 43 (:50) (Shotgun) T.Brady pass short right to W.Welker to MIA 43 for 14 yards (T.Culver). P15

Timeout #3 by NE at 00:44.

1-10-MIA 43 (:44) (Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete deep right to S.Aiken.

Tom BradyAPPatriots QB Tom Brady

PENALTY on MIA-T.Culver, Defensive Pass Interference, 17 yards, enforced at MIA 43 - No Play. X16

1-10-MIA 26 (:38) (Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete short middle to S.Aiken.

2-10-MIA 26 (:34) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady pass short right to W.Welker ran ob at MIA 12 for 14 yards. P17

1-10-MIA 12 (:30) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete short left to B.Green-Ellis.

2-10-MIA 12 (:23) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady sacked at MIA 16 for -4 yards (C.Wake). HAD THEY RUN THE BALL ANY TIME ABOVE THE HALF WOULD HAVE BEEN OVER AT THIS POINT.

3-14-MIA 16 (:04) (No Huddle, Shotgun) T.Brady pass incomplete short right to R.Moss.

4-14-MIA 16 (:01) S.Gostkowski 34-yard field goal is GOOD, Center-J.Ingram, Holder-C.Hanson.

MIA 10 NE 16, 10 plays, 70 yards, 2 penalties, 1:43 drive, 15:00 elapsed

These three points could have easily been avoided had the Fins made the right call when they had the ball.

Not often can you find a Colts game where Peyton Manning makes a mistake with his end-of- the-half game management, but this one was a huge blunder and really allowed the Texans to get back into the game mentally and emotionally. The Texans were driving to a score when they fumbled, allowing the Colts to get the ball with two minutes and their full complement of timeouts. Meanwhile, the Texans had two timeouts left. Here’s the drive:

Indianapolis Colts at 2:00

Peyton ManningAPColts QB Peyton Manning

1-10-IND 20 (2:00) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass incomplete short left to R.Wayne (G.Quin).

2-10-IND 20 (1:54) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass incomplete short middle to D.Clark (G.Quin).

3-10-IND 20 (1:50) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass incomplete short middle to D.Clark (E.Wilson).

PENALTY on HST-E.Wilson, Unnecessary Roughness, 15 yards, enforced at IND 20 - No Play. X17

1-10-IND 35 (1:46) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass short left to R.Wayne ran ob at IND 48 for 13 yards. P18

1-10-IND 48 (1:38) P.Manning pass short right to D.Clark to HST 46 for 6 yards (D.Ryans).

2-4-HST 46 (1:25) (No Huddle) P.Manning pass incomplete short right to P.Garcon (B.Pollard).

3-4-HST 46 (1:21) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass short left to J.Addai ran ob at HST 34 for 12 yards. P19

1-10-HST 34 (1:17) P.Manning pass short left to R.Wayne ran ob at HST 22 for 12 yards. P20

PERFECT CHANCE TO CALL A RUN AND KEEP THE CLOCK MOVING.

1-10-HST 22 (1:12) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass incomplete deep left to A.Collie.

2-10-HST 22 (1:07) (Shotgun) P.Manning pass short middle intended for J.Addai INTERCEPTED by B.Pollard at HST 14. B.Pollard to 50 for 36 yards (R.Lilja).

To start the drive, the Colts throw an incomplete pass, but they must get the clock moving in their favor. The last thing they want to do is punt the ball back to the explosive Houston offense. The Colts’ refusal to run the ball at any point here allows the Texans to make one play with enough time to attempt a long field goal. This play selection by the Colts is normal in terms of down and distance, but not in terms of the end of the half. They have to respect their opponents’ offense, even as good as their offense can be at times.

Check out our new team pages, where your voice is heard and where you can rate your favorite team’s coach, quarterback, coordinators and general manager.

Follow me on Twitter: michaelombardi

Comments

Add a Comment
VR
Nov 10, 2009
05:28 PM

Come on, Mike, you're taking your conclusions way beyond what the evidence will support. You're mistakenly assuming NE wouldn't have changed anything in their drive had they not had the timeout. But they clearly would have conserved time a bit more in various places (see the first play where a 7 yard pass took 24 seconds off the clock, for example).

You and I both know Tom Brady doesn't need 1:43 and a timeout to get 60 yards in a no-huddle. They were in FG range with :38 seconds left! He might have had fewer shots at the end zone, but that's about it.

Jamison
Nov 10, 2009
05:30 PM

I love McD, man. Just watching him at the podium, he seems like he's in charge and knows it all. It's not a cockiness, it's a confidence. This guy's a good coach and I'm looking forward to him getting a franchise QB and coaching my Broncs for a long time. He just sounds like a good coach.

Mr.Murder
Nov 10, 2009
05:57 PM

"The opponent in the second half is the clock." (for both teams).
-Bill Walsh
You might as well consider the clock ending the half to be part of the same thing.

T. Palumbi
Nov 10, 2009
06:20 PM

Whether a poor decision hurts the team depends on many different factors and circumstances. That doesn't make it NOT a poor decision.

Sirbud
Nov 10, 2009
08:16 PM

No love for Norvalicious? The Chargers ran the 2-minute drill perfectly, never calling their one timeout and leaving the Giants with only 15 seconds at the end of a one-point game. I expect such biased Norv-erlookings from Schatz and Simmons, but you're better than that Lombardi!!

Mike
Nov 10, 2009
09:49 PM

For Reid's last flag on the placement of the ball I thought the ref's hosed Philly. Looked like a first down all the way.

Jim
Nov 10, 2009
10:13 PM

How does McKid think he only needs 1:30 to score? He dinks and dunks and the league is catching on. Denver has not had one pass over 25 yards over the past two games and have scored 10 points in 8 quarters. This team may need well over 5 minutes to score. McD is taking a page out of Shanny's Jake Plummer offense.

Sirbud
Nov 10, 2009
10:23 PM

No love for Norvalicious? The Chargers ran the 2-minute drill perfectly, never calling their one timeout and leaving the Giants with only 15 seconds at the end of a one-point game. I expect such biased Norv-erlookings from Schatz and Simmons, but you're better than that Lombardi!!

LiveFreeOrDie
Nov 11, 2009
08:44 AM

VR - The point is not the outcome. The point is that if you consistently make the right decisons it is going to benifit more often thatn not.

Clearly circumstance and luck play a role, and are things you cant control. Would you rather have the Pats have to kick a 40 yrd FG at best, or be Inside the 20 with 2 shots at the end zone?

The Linc
Nov 11, 2009
10:25 AM

The worst was when Andy challenged the McCoy reception and assumed the refs had to give him the forward progress. But no one touched McCoy so he was obviously short of the 1st down. I wonder if Andy just didn't understand the exact rule on forward progress in that situation?

Yatrix
Nov 11, 2009
10:46 AM

@Jim

You missed the point, dude. The point was that you don't give Pitt the ball back with a large amount of time left. The idea of a two-minute offense is to get down the field in that amount of time. Sure, you want to score, but you also don't want to wipe out that score by giving up points, nor do you want to not score and net negative points.

McD made the right call, as Lombo stated. You don't approach the situation expecting to fail in your two minute offense. Not to mention, the thought is, if we're gonna score in a two minute offense against Pitt, the extra 30 seconds won't matter. Pitt would have to have defensive breakdowns for that to happen so the extra time is moot.

Also, Rivers ran that offense down the field on the Giants. That wasn't clock management by Norv Turner, that was phenominal QB play from Phillis Rivers. Not taking the time out when you don't need to is an obvious move, not a smart move. Lombo usually points out the smarter decisions or dumber decisions, not the common sense ones. That's why the columns are interesting and not masterminding the obvious.

Jim
Nov 11, 2009
11:19 AM

Yatrix, I get the point, I just don't always agree with it. Every game has an eb and flow to it. The Broncos dominated the 1st half by throwing the ball underneath and opposite of Troy P's side of the ball. Yet they were going to go into half time down by 4. If you don't trust your QB who had only thrown 2 interceptions all season and you don't trust your D which is one of the top ranked units, when do you trust them? I think his play calling spoke volumes to his team , which promptly went out and laid an egg in the 2nd half. If the score was reversed then I have no problem with this strategy.

KJ85
Nov 11, 2009
11:37 AM

I think it should be noted that the Patriots nearly screwed up their FG opportunity at the end of the half but were bailed out by shady homefield time-keeping. With 4-5 seconds left on the clock Brady threw into the end zone - a play that took at least 5 seconds - yet the time mysteriously stopped at 1 second allowing them to kick the field goal. That could have been a huge blunder had the home cooking not bailed them out.

KJ85
Nov 11, 2009
11:39 AM

I think it should be noted that the Patriots nearly screwed up their FG opportunity at the end of the half but were bailed out by shady homefield time-keeping. With 4-5 seconds left on the clock Brady threw into the end zone - a play that took at least 5 seconds - yet the time mysteriously stopped at 1 second allowing them to kick the field goal. That could have been a huge blunder had the home cooking not bailed them out.

yahoodave
Nov 11, 2009
12:50 PM

Mike...really??? no mention on how in the world NE got that 3d and 14 play off...and incomplete..in 3 seconds and still had a second left??? cmon mike...u were soind so good this year.....did bellicheck offer u a possible job next year???

Sirbud
Nov 11, 2009
02:04 PM

@Yatrix. Rivers was awesome, but during that two minute drive, he motioned twice to spike the ball (the last time after the Sproles pass but before the TD pass to V.Jackson) and Norv waived him off. While this may seem obvious to you, it doesn't appear to be for most coaches, which I thought was the point of the article. If Lombardi is going to praise McDaniels for managing a horrific and embarassing loss correctly, then I think a standing Norv-ation is in order for a coach who (with his QB) successfully managed a game-winning drive.

Drew T.
Nov 11, 2009
05:27 PM

It shouldn't be surprising that Denver reporters don't get football. They, like 'Bronco Country', are pretty sure the only way to play football is on the edge, trying to zip darts into double and triple coverage. We've run two QB's (Griese, Plummer) out of town over it, and worshipped 10% of Jay Cutler while minimizing the other 90% that Bearland now has to try to rationalize. I'm glad that McD has an unusually thick skin.

All you had to do was actually pay attention to the games against Baltimore and Pittsburgh to realize that Denver HAD to dink and dunk or let Kyle Orton get slaughtered. When you can't protect your QB, you can't go downfield, and you certainly don't want to have your QB hucking up prayers under extreme duress just because you're inside 2 minutes-- especially with Big Ben trolling the other side line. By that time, the Steelers had adjusted to the play action fakes, and the slants were working anymore. Luckily, not many teams have front sevens that are total mismatches against Denver's zone-scheme built interior. Meanwhile, McD will remain practical and try to maximize Denver's strengths rather than hope against hope that his team morphs into something it ain't just because the media and fans can't give up the ghost of John Elway.

Brad James
Nov 12, 2009
01:41 PM

The football gods have shined upon my Broncos numerous times in the past 30 years. First of all, we were given John Elway, Mike Shanahan, Ed McCaffrey, Rod Smith, etc. Now, we have obtained Josh McDaniels! The man is in command; all fears about the Broncos' short-term (and long-term) prospects dissipate once he addresses the media. There is something about John Carroll University that begets greatness: McDaniels, Don Shula and even London Fletcher are all alums. Yes, I can rest easy with McDaniels at the helm. Mr. Bowlen is an awesome owner and he NEVER gets the credit he deserves. Thanks again, Lombardi!

Next 1 - 18 of 18 Prev COMMENTS

Add a Comment

* Required - Keep track of your comments Login or Register with NFP
(will not be published)