|
| 01 |
Kenny Vaccaro FS, Texas |
6-1 |
218 |
8.3 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Vaccaro has the speed and explosiveness to be extremely effective in all types of coverage. His QAB allows him to change directions fluidly and consistently make tackles in the open field. He takes excellent angles of pursuit and is adept at squaring up and driving through the ball carrier when he keeps his feet. He has a good feel for the game and is quick to diagnose and attack the ball, allowing him to make plays all over the field regardless of his alignment. He has the length and height to effectively reach around the receiver to play the ball.
WEAKNESSES - Vaccaro looks thinner than listed and his NFL team will likely want him to add 10-15 lbs to his frame. He struggles to consistently defeat blockers and must be more aggressive with his hands and use his length to prevent blockers from locking on. At times he is too aggressive in run support and leaves his feet when attempting tackle, causing him to whiff completely.
SUMMARY - Kenny Vaccaro is a highly impressive athlete and is one of the most complete safety prospects to enter the NFL the past several years. His elite speed and explosiveness allows him to make plays all over the field vs. the run and pass, and his agility and smoothness allow him to play under control despite playing at such a high speed. His most impressive effort this season came against West Virginia, when he went man-to-man for much of the night vs. the explosive and elusive Tavon Austin and more than held his own. He is outstanding on run plays outside the box, as he takes excellent angles to the boundary and is able to stay square to his target and finish effectively in space. His ability to slide down and play nickel back only adds to his value at the next level, as coverage ability is paramount for safeties in today's NFL which is so often based on spreading the field and exposing isolated match-ups. I fully expect Vaccaro to hear his name called on day one of the draft, as he is clearly one of the top defensive backs in this class.
|
|
| 02 |
Jonathan Cyprien FS, Florida International |
6-1 |
210 |
8.0 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Cyprien has very good height, length and bulk for the safety position. He demonstrates excellent playing speed in space, and uses his natural agility and explosiveness to effectively close on plays in front and to the boundary. He demonstrates excellent lateral quickness and can transition into chase mode effectively in pass coverage. He is extremely aggressive from off coverage, and does a nice job of consistently breaking in front of routes to gain inside positioning. He plays the ball in the air as if it were intended for him, showing the ability to pluck the ball at its highest point for interceptions. He does an excellent job of breaking down in space to consistently finish tackles in the open field.
WEAKNESSES - While Cyprien displays very good instincts in man coverage and when playing the run, the same cannot be said about his play in zone coverage or against play-action fakes. When asked to play cover three in games I graded he struggled to quickly identify deep routes in his area and was consequently at times a beat late moving toward the ball. When lined up in the box, he tended to freeze up when faced with PA, and too often allowed his man to get behind him. He also needs to stay low in his pedal, as he tends to get high and choppy, which can limit COD.
SUMMARY - Jonathan Cyprien was an exciting player to evaluate, as he has the size, athleticism and physicality to be a force on the back end at the next level. He is an aggressive player in the box that shows the ability to consistently wrap up and finish tackles as well as use his physicality to cover bigger TEs effectively. From off coverage he displays outstanding instincts, as he consistently diagnoses routes quickly and cuts off routes before his receiver can get out of his break. When the ball is in the air he attacks it like a receiver, and shows solid hands on balls outside of his frame. He needs to improve his feel for zone coverage from a deep alignment and do a better job of recovering against play-action passes, but he is a well-rounded player ready to make a big impact in the NFL. He will surely hear his name called and day one, and could be gone within the first 20 picks.
|
|
| 03 |
Eric Reid FS, Louisiana State |
6-2 |
212 |
7.5 E |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Few safeties possess Reid's athleticism to be impact players in coverage and run support. Flashes quickness coming up field in run support, when Eric stays over feet and keeps his knees bent he can make violent hits while wrapping up with good technique. Reid has sideline range against the run, can avoid contact/blockers on the move and has a good closing burst to finish plays. He does a good job of reading the QB/Pass from deep alignment, closes fast on passes in front of him and is willing to make hard hit right after the catch. From approx. 10 yards off the LOS he flashes excellent read of quick hitting pass to receiver, closes explosively and makes violent hit right after the catch. He has experience covering receivers and shows the hips and speed to stay with him off the LOS and across the field on "drag" route.
WEAKNESSES - Reid is an elite talent, but does not play up to his talent consistently. While he flashes coming up the field fast in run support, at times he seems content to sit back and let teammates make the play. He is not a consistently good tackler - Too often he either stops feet and launches himself to make hard hit and ends up missing or he stops feet and waits for ball carrier to come to him and can be juked or trampled too easily. When lined up in deep coverage he has a tendency to go for the hit when he closes on receiver rather than trying to break-up pass.
SUMMARY - A junior who came out early for the 2013 NFL Draft, Reid definitely has first round physical talent, but his on field play is more of a second/third round player. At over 6'1, Reid's quick feet, loose hips and playing speed enable him to be effective covering receivers in man coverage and flashes the ability to reach in front of receiver to break up pass. When he is aggressive coming up the field on plays in front of him, stays over his feet, under control and uses proper technique he can be a strong, physical wrap-up tackler. He has experience making big plays on special teams coverage units and should be able to immediately contribute on them while he develops as a safety. Overall, Reid is a gifted safety who has the talent to not only be a versatile play-maker in the NFL, but would warrant a first round pick if he had been consistent at LSU. Some team will likely draft him in the second round because of his potential to become the player he has the physical talent to be. I think he will become a productive starting safety, but will always struggle with inconsistent tackling.
|
|
| 04 |
Josh Evans FS, Florida |
6-2 |
201 |
7.2 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Evans is a strong and physical player. He has the ability to break off blocks well. Gets off the snap quickly and has the ability to explode to the quarterback. Very sound tackler and is a guy who looks to make the big hit. He is never out of a play because of his quickness and playing speed. He has excellent sideline to sideline speed and has the ability to close strong and make the play. He has the ability to chase a guy down from behind to make a tackle. He has great sideline to sideline speed. He has excellent footwork and quick feet on his backpedal. He is able to plant his feet well and explode to the ball off of his backpedal. He has very solid hip turn and is able to recover well against the route. He is more effective in zone coverage as he does such a good job of reading and reacting to the QB/Pass and has an explosive closing burst to the ball to make a play on the ball or deliver a hit right after the ball arrives. In zone coverage he has the ability to break nicely off his backpedal and either make a play for an interception or if it's a short pass he has the ability to explode to make the tackle.
WEAKNESSES - Evans pass coverage is something he will need to work on in order to have a much bigger impact. I do not feel as though he is a guy that is going to be able to play tight coverage from the LOS at the next level. He also has a tendency to be inpatient at times, although very rarely. His aggressiveness leads him to jump/bite on pump fakes and fakes by receiver, which can be fatal in the NFL.
SUMMARY - Overall Evans is a very physical football player. He's a guy that you can always count on to make a play and be around the ball. Evans reacts quickly to plays and gets started towards the ball fast. He has the ability to explode to the football and has excellent tackling technique. He is able to square up the runner and put on a hard hit. The questions I have are whether or not he can be consistent enough in pass coverage. He has the tools to be a very effective safety at the next level, but he needs to be more patient and allow the play to come to him. He's very athletic and sometimes I feel he takes that for granted. Overall, I feel Evans will be a good starting safety in the NFL. He will however need to become more consistent covering tight ends in man coverage and control his aggressiveness to avoid biting on fakes. The way he sniffs out the play and as physical as he is, I would not be surprised if he saw some time at OLB in certain defensive packages and should enable him to be an impact special teams player immediately.
|
|
| 05 |
Jamoris Slaughter FS, Notre Dame |
6-0 |
200 |
6.4 J |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Slaughter is a very good athlete with the speed needed to run with TEs and slot receivers in man coverage. He stays low in his pedal and is fluid transitioning on his flip, allowing him to consistently maintain proper positioning when in man coverage. When playing zone coverage in the box he is physical with receivers through his area and does a good job of reading the QB and maintaining discipline with his assignment. Despite having just average size, he is a very effective player against the run when lined up in the box. He is aggressive and physical with blockers, allowing him to consistently shed in time to get involved in run support. He takes good angles of pursuit to the boundary and displays the ability to consistently break down in space and finish.
WEAKNESSES - Slaughter played only three games during his senior year as an Achilles injury ended his season early and has kept him from participating in all-star games and the combine drills. He has a thin frame and will need to add bulk to play safety at the next level. While he possesses good top end speed, he is not an innately explosive player when trying to break and close from off the ball. He needs to improve his ball skills, as he will at times struggle locating the ball in the air in time to break up passes.
SUMMARY - Jamoris Slaughter has slipped through this draft season relatively unnoticed by the media because of the Achilles injury that cut his senior season short, but his play as a junior at Notre Dame is clearly on par or better than that of many of the 2nd tier prospects at the position this year. He is a smooth, fluid athlete that stays disciplined in his assignments and his techniques, allowing him to be extremely effective in all types of coverage. He possesses the speed to cover most slot receivers in man to man, and the physicality to take on flex TEs. Slaughter is also impressive against the run, as he is aggressive with blockers and consistently breaks down to finish tackles in space. He will need to add another 10-15 lbs of bulk to his frame but if he can recover from his current injury and maintain his health long term, Slaughter has the skill set to develop into a starter.
|
|
| 06 |
D.J. Swearinger FS, South Carolina |
6-0 |
210 |
5.9 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Swearinger has the size and strength to deliver big time hits that help separate the ball from the receiver. He consistently fills holes and wraps up nicely to make the sure tackle. Has the ability to play both near the line of scrimmage and drop back into coverage which shows his versatility. He uses his hands well to hold his ground and get off blocks. He shows good in space coordination and agility that make him affective to bring down ball carriers. He has the athletic ability to cover tight ends and running backs well in man coverage.
WEAKNESSES - D.J. is limited in coverage when in man where he to often allows the receiver to make catches infront of him and then makes a play on the ball. He does not show the ability to plant and drive on the ball while it is in the air. Too often he gets caught flat footed because he is staring in on the QB and allows WRs to get over the top. Once he is beat he does not show the recovery speed to make up for his mistakes. He does not show the ability to make game changing plays like interceptions or cause fumbles.
SUMMARY - D.J. Swearinger is a three year starter as a safety for this strong Gamecock Defense. Even as a true freshman he played in every game due to his physical mental makeup and solid technique. He rarely makes mistakes except when being overly aggressive. He is a solid run stopper and plays well in space due to playing with a quality base. He has the flexibility to play both the Strong and Free Safety spots at the next level and should be a very good fit for a team that runs a Tampa 2 style defense where he can be more interchangeable. He is best suited in zone coverage where he will not be exploited for his lack of top line speed. He does not show great ball skills, due to the lack on turnovers he has produced in his college career. The game is not too big for him and he should be able to translate immediately at the NFL level. Worst case scenario is he is a solid special teamer and adds quality depth to a defensive backfield. He could work his way to being a starter but don't expect him to be a difference maker but more a strong piece to the puzzle that doesn't make the big error. Overall Swearinger is a great pick up in the 4th round and should have a long NFL career for some team.
|
|
| 07 |
T.J. McDonald FS, Southern California |
6-3 |
205 |
5.5 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - McDonald definitely looks the part of an NFL safety "on the hoof" with his thick, muscular build. When playing aggressively, he has shown a willingness to come up the field quickly in run support and can make strong, violent tackles when he stays over his feet and under control. Showing off his versatility, he lines up deep and near the line of scrimmage in different defensive alignments, can avoid blocks and is constantly around the ball. Surprising acceleration and playing speed give McDonald excellent range vs. the run and pass. He flashes an explosive closing burst to finish plays with hard hits/tackles. When he reads the QB/Pass correctly, he flashes the ability close fast on passes in front of him and makes hard tackle right after the catch. Despite his size, he has the quickness and speed to cover tight ends in man coverage.
WEAKNESSES - Despite having the size and athleticism of an elite prospect, McDonald does not produce like one. Right now he is a much better athlete than football player and needs to improve his production if he wants to start in the NFL. While he flashes quickness coming up quickly in run support, he does not do it consistently and goes through stretches where he seems content to sit back and allow his teammates to make the tackle. Like many defensive players, McDonald loves making the "blow up" hit and it leads to him launching himself to try and make big hit too often and ends up missing tackles he should make. Additionally, when he is not going for the big hit he tends to become an upright, grab tackler. For a player with his experience, it is surprising that he does not read and react consistently in coverage and if often a beat late reacting to sideline and deep passes. He is much more effective going forward in pass coverage than he is in deep coverage and has not shown the skills to come down and be effective covering slot receivers at the next level.
SUMMARY - For a player with elite physical talent, it was frustrating to evaluate McDonald because he does not impact games the way he is capable of. The son of former NFL All Pro safety Tim McDonald, T.J. has a lot to live up to and to do that he will need to play at a higher level than he did at USC. For a player with three years starting experience, it surprises me at how inconsistent McDonald is reading and reacting to pass plays from a deep alignment. He has shown the ability to be an intimidating hitter/tackler in run support and on passes in front of him, but his missed tackles make him a risky player to have at the back end of your defense. Overall, I am confident that McDonald will test out very well at the Combine and will end up being drafted higher than I have him graded. However, I do not believe he will ever be a consistently productive starter in the NFL and will always struggle with missed tackles and in deep coverage.
|
|
| 08 |
Bacarri Rambo FS, Georgia |
6-0 |
210 |
5.4 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Instinctive and aware, Rambo consistently maintains excellent positioning in deep coverage. He does a good job of reading the QB/Pass/Route-Combinations from centerfield and breaks and closes fast on passes in front of him. Length and ball skills allow him to easily make plays to break-up and intercept passes - His ball skills have been on display a lot as he always seems to be in the right place to make a big interception in key situations. His ability to read and react to the play so quickly gives him sideline range, both in coverage and against the run. He consistently has shown the ability to get outside to help the cornerback with over-the-top coverage. Unlike many thin safeties who excel in coverage, Rambo has no hesitation coming up field quickly in run support. He does a good job of avoiding blocks and closing to the ball carrier fast. When he stays over his feet and under control he can be a strong, wrap-up tackler out in space.
WEAKNESSES - Rambo is a better football player than all-around athlete. While he has quick feet and a quick and compact backpedal, he is tight in hips, which limits his ability to flip hips to change directions fast. On film and at his pro day, Rambo struggled when he had to turn and run out of pedal and could not transition out of pedal quick enough to close fast on passes in front of him out of a pedal. Although he has shown the ability to be a strong open field tackler, too often his tackling technique is an issue. He has a bad habit of either stopping feet and lunging/diving to try and make low tackle or staying upright and becomes a catch tackler - These both lead to him missing too many tackles.
SUMMARY - The classic safety who slides on draft day, but becomes a solid starter in the NFL, Rambo's combination of excellent production at college and less than elite athleticism make him "that guy." It is never wise to write off a defensive backs athletic limitations, but when you look at the entire package of Rambo's skills it is clear he has what it takes to become a starting coverage safety in the NFL. He is definitely better playing passes in front of him and helping cornerbacks on sideline routes, but is not as effective when he has to change directions fast to adjust in man coverage. Overall, Rambo is a player that required a lot of extra film work to make sure I was correct evaluating his skill set. The more I watched, the more I was reminded of Madieu Williams who has been a solid safety in the NFL.
|
|
| 09 |
Brandan Bishop FS, North Carolina State |
6-2 |
205 |
5.4 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Naturally instinctive Bishop consistently reads and reacts to the play quickly. Unlike many free/coverage safeties, he consistently comes up the field quickly in run support, can avoid blockers and can break down and make strong, technically sound tackles out in space. His ability to read and react quickly helps him to consistently play faster than his timed speed. He has sideline range to chase down ball carriers in pursuit and to get out to the sideline to help the cornerback in over-the-top coverage. He does an excellent job of reading the QB/Pass from deep coverage and can plant, drive and close quickly on passes in front of him. In games and during the all-star games practices he displayed the ball skills to break up and intercept passes.
WEAKNESSES - More of a smooth athlete than a quick, twitch one, Bishop lacks the explosiveness and top end speed to cover fast tight ends and slot receivers in man coverage which is vital for safeties in today's NFL. His quick read and aggressiveness coming up in run support leads to him biting on fakes at times and it leaves him out of position. When he loses a step in coverage, he lacks the burst and speed to catch up and get back into good coverage position. Not being a top athlete also leads to him missing some tackles - Not due to bad technique, but rather he cannot adjust to quick cuts by ball carrier.
SUMMARY - Bishop is an under-rated safety who is constantly around the ball and makes more plays against the run and in coverage than expected. A smart and instinctive defender who consistently reads and reacts to the play fast, Bishop impressed with his consistency on film and at the East West Shrine Game. In addition to being a productive safety, he has the tools to be an excellent special teams player. Overall, Bishop is not a player I expected much from when I began evaluating NC State, but it is clear he has many of the tools to challenge to become a starter in the NFL. He is not a player that I would draft high, but in the fourth or fifth round I would take a shot on him because I believe he is the type of safety that often comes into the NFL as an afterthought and then develops into a solid, workmanlike starter.
|
|
| 10 |
J.J. Wilcox FS, Georgia Southern |
6-0 |
215 |
5.4 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Wilcox has good height and an excellent build for the safety position. His bulk allows him to dish out and absorb punishment, as he has the potential to be a physical enforcer on the back end. He is an effective player against the run because of his strong base and leverage, and his ability to consistently break down in space. This allows him to take strong angles of pursuit, and stay square to his target. When he keeps his feet, he consistently finishes tackles in space. When playing zone coverage from in the box, he does a solid job of identifying route concepts, showing the ability to cut off routes through his zone and make plays on the ball.
WEAKNESSES - Wilcox lacks instincts and physicality in man coverage, which is not surprising considering he was a WR before 2012. When he allows his man a free release off the LOS our out of his break in man coverage, he struggles to stay with him in transition, and lacks the makeup speed to close the difference. He also at times is caught guessing on his man's initial move, making him susceptible to double moves when matched up one on one. From zone he allows too many catches in front because of his average closing ability, and when he is in position he does not consistently use his length to his advantage to break up passes. While consistently in position to make plays against the run, at times he leaves his feet and misses the ball carrier entirely.
SUMMARY - JJ Wilcox is a player teams will need to have patience with, as he is not ready to contribute at the NFL level outside of a special teams role. He was a WR at Georgia Southern until his senior campaign, and is clearly still learning the position. While he has the size and natural strength to be an effective player in man coverage, he is not physical at the POA and struggles to stay with his man in transition because he is consistently a beat late flipping his hips and lacks the speed to recover once he's lost a step. While he demonstrates the ability to read and attack routes through his area in zone coverage, he tends to go purely for the tackle and does not consistently attack the ball in the air. His best attribute right now is his ability in run support, as he takes surprisingly good angles for a player used to being on the other side of the ball and flashes the ability to break down and change directions against moving targets. His ability to tackle in space should help him make an NFL roster as a special teams player on both coverage units, which will buy him time as teams try to develop his skills in coverage. He is worth a 5th or 6th round selection, and don't be surprised to see a team experiment with him at LB, as he has the base to pack on more weight and may be a better fit at OLB with his skills against the run.
|