|
| 11 |
Luke Joeckel OT, Texas A&M |
6-6 |
310 |
8.2 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Joeckel is an elite athlete that plays with outstanding quickness, agility and balance. His wide base and leverage allows him to shuffle side to side with ease to adjust to counter moves. He is quick off the LOS and does an excellent job of staying under control when out in space. He consistently diagnoses games and blitzes correctly and works well with his fellow linemen to make pre and post-snap adjustments.
WEAKNESSES - Joeckel lacks elite natural strength and can be driven backward by aggressive bull rushers despite excellent leverage. He lacks a consistent punch and tends to attack his man outside his frame, allowing the defender to establish positioning inside. On run blocks he struggles to get consistent movement off the LOS and has to rely on technique and athleticism to tie his man up and sustain blocks.
SUMMARY - Texas A&M Freshman QB Johnny Manziel improvised his way to the Heisman Trophy and a critical part of his success was the consistency and productivity of left tackle Luke Joeckel. Joeckel combines outstanding quickness, agility and balance with consistent base and leverage to make himself a highly efficient pass blocker. He has an excellent kick slide off the snap and is consistently able to protect the edge with his quickness and length. He isn't a mauler-type and needs to focus on consistent hand placement, but his ability to maintain blocks to the whistle on overly extended plays sets him apart from the rest of the draft class (of course, outside his teammate Jake Matthews). Overall, Joeckel has a shot at being the top pick of the draft, should start as a rookie and looks like a future pro-bowler.
|
|
| 12 |
Sylvester Williams DT, North Carolina |
6-3 |
305 |
8.15 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Williams is an innately explosive athlete that also displays impressive agility for a man his size when playing with proper knee bend and leverage. When he comes off the snap low he display very good strength at the POA and the heavy hands needed to take on and shed multiple blockers. He demonstrates outstanding instincts off the snap and excellent read and react skills, allowing him to use his non-stop hustle to make plays he otherwise wouldn't be able to get to.
WEAKNESSES - Too often Williams comes off the snap high and doesn't play with proper knee bend and base. This allows blockers to get into his framework and control him at the POA, as well as prevents him from breaking down in space to consistently finish tackles. He goes to his swim move too often on the pass rush, leading to him being washed out too easily by aggressive blockers.
SUMMARY - For all the (justified) hype Sharrif Floyd and Sheldon Richardson have received, Sylvester Williams is every bit the same level of prospect at DT. He possesses an outstanding first step and excellent instincts, which allow him to constantly penetrate gaps and threaten the backfield. When playing with proper base and leverage he demonstrates excellent strength at the POA, and uses his hands aggressively to shed blocks. When rushing the passer he flashes a variety of moves utilizes his natural quickness and power, but he tends to rely too much on his first step quickness and arm-over move. Once he learns to lower his pad level off the ball utilize his full skill set, he will become a highly productive player in almost any defensive scheme. Williams is clearly worth a first round selection, and should be able to make an immediate impact in the NFL with his burst off the ball.
|
|
| 13 |
Tyler Eifert TE, Notre Dame |
6-6 |
251 |
8.1 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Eifert has the height and bulk NFL teams love for the TE position. He is a very smooth athlete capable of running precise route and creating natural separation off his breaks against LBs playing man coverage. He is a physical, explosive player with the ball in the air that consistently demonstrates the ability to adjust his body and high point the ball to secure catches in traffic while absorbing heavy hits. He is a competitive runner after the catch and a willing blocker that demonstrates natural lower body flexibility and foot quickness.
WEAKNESSES - While a fluid athlete, Eifert lacks explosive vertical speed and has to rely on his size, physicality and competitiveness to create separation against defensive backs. While a competitive blocker, he tends to bend at the waist instead of his knees, which causes him to fall off blockers early in space. Despite showing natural fluidity while making cuts he has a tendency to get too high on his breaks which limits his ability to accelerate and create consistent separation.
SUMMARY - Tyler Eifert is an impressive physical specimen that is ready to make an instant impact in the NFL. He has the size, fluidity and physicality to run strong routes and create consistent separation against LBs, and possesses the body control to adjust to balls outside of his frame. He has soft hands that allow him to pluck the ball away from his body naturally, and consistently wins 50/50 balls because of his explosive leaping ability and strength at the POA. While he is an inconsistent blocker because of his tendency to get too far out front of himself and lose his balance, he is a willing combatant at the LOS and shows the ability to use his size and natural quickness to get his feet around and seal his man out when playing in-line. Eifert is a matchup nightmare capable of playing in-line or flexed out in the slot and is ready to make huge plays in the passing game for whichever team drafts him in the 1st round.
|
|
| 14 |
Barkevious Mingo OLB, Louisiana State |
6-5 |
240 |
8.1 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - A rare athlete with exceptional closing ability, Mingo is a dominating, impact defender when he plays aggressively and uses good technique. Although he does not always do it, when he anticipates the snap and is playing aggressively he has great first step quickness and the speed to out race the OT around the corner. His initial quickness enables him to play stronger than his measured size as he can jolt and drive OT backwards when he uses hands well and maintains leverage. Excellent foot quickness and agility allow Mingo to change directions in a flash, which helps him beat pass blocks with an outstanding spin move. Using his hands well to keep blockers off him helps him to consistently defeat/avoid OL run blocks to make plays on run at him. When he is unblocked he attacks the play and constantly makes big, impact plays behind the LOS.
WEAKNESSES - Mingo is not nearly as consistent as he needs to be. He goes through stretches where he pops upright at the snap and does not pass rush aggressively and when he doesn't he is non-effective. While he is muscular, he lacks the bulk to handle being a full-time DE in a 43 defense the way that most teams run their schemes. Even though he has a great spin move to beat pass blocker, he needs to tighten it up when he spins to the outside as he tends to get too far up the field after spinning and cannot get back into good position quick enough. On running plays away he does not consistently start down the LOS quickly, which limits his ability to make as many plays as he is capable of. His statistical production is not what it should have been.
SUMMARY - One of the harder players I evaluated this year, Mingo required much more time than most elite prospects to get a good feel for as he handled a number of assignments and because of his responsibilities he was not as statistically productive or involved as a player with his talent usually is. Although he will never be a big, stout run defender who can consistently anchor and shed OL run blocks at the NFL level, his use of hands, quickness and instincts help him to stay free from and avoid blocks and explode to the ball to make the play. Overall, if my team played a 43 defense I would only use a first round pick on him if the coaches were going to tailor the defensive scheme around his talents as his lack of bulk/size would hinder his production if he lined up close to OT all the time. If used as a wide rusher in a 43 scheme or an outside linebacker in a 34 scheme then I would definitely draft him in the first round as I believe he can be a dynamic, play-maker who impacts games as a run defender and pass rusher. .
|
|
| 15 |
Sheldon Richardson DT, Missouri |
6-4 |
295 |
8.1 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Richardson has an excellent combination of quickness, agility and balance, which he combines with outstanding instincts off the ball to consistently win gaps. When he stays low off the snap and gets his hands out quickly, he displays the violent hands needed to set up a variety of moves to defeat blockers. He plays aggressively from snap to whistle, and does an outstanding job of reading and reacting to the ball behind the LOS.
WEAKNESSES - Richardson lacks top end speed and is not able to consistently finish plays in pursuit. He also lacks natural explosiveness out of his stance, and must rely on quickness, instincts and hand usage to defeat blockers and penetrate the backfield. When rushing the passer he relies too heavily on his swim, despite possessing a full arsenal of moves. At times he gets too high at the snap and can be driven off the ball or neutralized at the LOS by aggressive drive blockers.
SUMMARY - Sheldon Richardson was an exciting player to evaluate because he plays at such a consistently high level. He displays the athleticism and timing off the snap to win gaps, as well as the anchor and heavy hands needed to occupy and work off blockers at the LOS. While he lacks natural explosion and long speed he is effective in space because of his read and react skills, as well as his ability to break down and change directions efficiently. Richardson's intensity and passion for football not only show up in his play on the field but also during interviews, and teams are sure to fall in love with his intangibles as well. He is likely to be a top 20 pick and should develop into a highly productive NFL player as either a 43 DT or 34 DE.
|
|
| 16 |
Tavon Austin WR, West Virginia |
5-9 |
171 |
8.1 G |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - One of the most explosive players in the country, Austin has the rare athletic tools to be a game changing player in the NFL. Quick off ball into route and explosive out of his cuts, Austin is easily able to gain separation from man coverage. Not only does he get separation with a burst out of his cuts, but he has the elite playing speed to pull away and get separation on deep routes. When defenses try to protect deep by playing zone, Austin has a good feel for finding open spots. Fearless heading into traffic, Austin does not peek at the defense and consistently catches the ball right before getting hit. Soft, natural hands combine with excellent concentration so that he catches nearly every pass thrown his way (In the games evaluated he caught over 95% of passes thrown to him). Austin is able to catch passes that get on top of him quickly because he gets his head and hands around fast when he comes out of cuts. Quick getting started up the field after the catch, Austin is naturally instinctive running in the open field. He follows blockers well, can make explosive cuts off their blocks and has the elusiveness to easily make tacklers miss in the open field. In addition to being a big play threat as a receiver, he is as dangerous as a punt and kickoff returner, which only increases his value.
WEAKNESSES - Obviously, the big issue is that at just over 5'8 Austin lacks the size NFL teams prefer. Historically, NFL teams shy away from drafting even the best receivers who measure under 5'9, so Austin could slide into the second or third round despite being a premier prospect. Not asked to run a wide variety of routes at West Virginia, Austin will have to become more polished running the entire "route tree."
SUMMARY - While evaluating quarterback Geno Smith was enjoyable, Tavon Austin's explosive playmaking ability was the best part of grading West Virginia this year. Way too often people say that a receiver or running back is a touchdown threat every time he touches the ball and most of the time that is an exaggeration, but in Austin's case it is spot on. In today's NFL where big receivers are the "in" thing, premier slot receivers like Wes Welker have proven to be invaluable and with Austin's big play ability he should become a star quickly. Although few receivers under 5'10 ever become dominant number one receivers, I am confident Austin has the tools to become such a player, similar to the Panthers' Steve Smith. Overall, Austin is likely going to be a first round pick because he is more explosive than recent first round picks Kendall Wright and Jeremy Maclin. I believe that Austin will become an impact player who makes big plays as a receiver and returner throughout his career. His on field play reminds me a lot of current Eagles star DeSean Jackson.
|
|
| 17 |
Sharrif Floyd DT, Florida |
6-3 |
303 |
8.05 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Floyd has the bulk and length required to play on the LOS. He displays solid natural strength at the POA when playing with proper leverage, and excels at stacking and shedding his man in time to make plays on runs in the box. He demonstrates very good read and react skills, and is surprisingly efficient at taking angles to the boundary and staying square to his target. He plays with non-stop effort from whistle to whistle which allows him to make plays other athletes his size simply can't.
WEAKNESSES - While Floyd generally displays solid QAB he is not innately explosive off the snap and struggles to consistently penetrate gaps. Once he gets his momentum up to full speed he struggles to break down and finish plays, losing out on numerous sack opportunities in games I graded. At times he gets too upright at the snap and can be driven off the ball on run plays. He lacks refinement in his pass rush moves, and must rely primarily on his hustle and ability to maul his man to get to the QB.
SUMMARY - Sharrif Floyd plays with a combination of power and competitiveness that few linemen can match. He flashes outstanding stack and shed ability and demonstrates very good football instincts. His most impressive trait is his ability to pursue laterally to the edge and finish by taking excellent angles and staying square to the RB, allowing him to adjust to cutbacks. What keeps him from being an elite prospect is his average burst off the snap and bad habit of getting upright at the snap, as can be moved off the ball despite his excellent natural strength. 34 teams will consider him a 5-technique end, while 43 teams would be wise to put him at LDE on rushing downs, and kick him inside to rush the passer on 3rd down. If he can learn to play with more consistent leverage off the ball and use his hands to set up a wider variety of pass moves, he has a chance to develop into one of the most versatile defensive linemen in this draft class.
|
|
| 18 |
Gavin Escobar TE, San Diego State |
6-6 |
255 |
8.05 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - There isn't a more natural pass-catcher at the position than Escobar. He has super-long arms and big hands, and he consistently plucks the ball away from his frame. He is a graceful athlete with a long stride, and his future is bright because of his ability to stretch the field and go up to get the ball. He has surprising quickness and can quickly separate from defensive backs as he gets out of his break. Escobar has deceptive ability to run away from defenders and is a very polished route runner, using his head and shoulders to sell fakes.
WEAKNESSES - Escobar is not a great blocker who is going to overpower defenders in the in-line blocking game. He does a better job using his body to wall off a defender, but it is an area where he needs to improve if he is going to help his teammates. He might end up being a good blocker with some time in an NFL strength and training program, as he lacks the strength to line up and push players around the field.
SUMMARY - Gavin Escobar comes into the NFL at a perfect time for his set of skills. Teams are using the hybrid tight end to stretch the field with their length, long arms and ability to wall off defenders because of the size of their bodies. Escobar brings all of these skills to the NFL table and more as he has great hands and catches everything that is thrown at him. He consistently catches the ball away from his body, making it more difficult for defenses to cover him. He shows explosion in and out of his breaks, and he eats up cushion quickly when lined up from the slot. Linebackers can't stay with him because of his movement ability, and cornerbacks can't stay with him because of his size. His ability to run after the catch is truly underrated because he can move laterally and avoid the tackler, and then run into open space. He consistently can locate the ball, make an adjustment with his body and make the catch. This might be Escobar's best trait, and his biggest asset going forward. He makes tough catches look easy and will make a quarterback more accurate with his huge catching radius. He has incredible hands, and makes contested catches all over the field. Escobar is going to present significant challenges to NFL defenses because of his ability to play jump ball in the red zone and down the seam. If he can improve in the blocking area, he will be the complete package and a rock star in the NFL. He warrants consideration in the middle of Round 1, and should be in consideration to be the first tight end off the board in April.
|
|
| 19 |
Cornellius Carradine DE, Florida State |
6-5 |
265 |
8.0 J MEDICAL |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Carradine's production in his first, and only, season as a starter at Florida State was impressive. You would never guess that he has limited starting experience when you see his variety of polished pass rush moves. He uses his hands extremely well to slap the pass blocker's hands down to stay free and can beat him inside or around the corner. Outstanding technique taking on run blocker at the POA, Carradine jolts blocker upright, holds ground, sheds and makes tackle consistently on runs at him. When left unblocked on the backside he does an excellent job of maintaining backside contain and making sure the play is going away before crashing down the LOS. When offenses try to "reach block" him on the backside he gets inside blocker consistently, keeps blocker on back and has elite speed chasing down the play in pursuit. On the handful of snaps that Carradine dropped off the ball into coverage he looked surprisingly smooth and fluid moving out in space and seemed to have a good sense and awareness.
WEAKNESSES - Obviously, the most pressing question surrounds Carradine's recovery from the torn right ACL that he suffered in the fourth quarter against Florida. If NFL medical personnel determine that he will make a full recovery then he will likely be a first round pick. Despite being an elite pass rusher, Carradine lacks an explosive first step off the ball. In addition to his recovery from injury, Carradine's lack of playing experience is a concern because players who only started one year in college have a history of failure in the NFL. This is an even bigger concern because he did not even complete one full season as a starter after injuring his knee.
SUMMARY - In the first few games evalauting Florida State, Carradine impressed me and then the more film I evaluated he continued to jump off the film. For a player with limited experience, I was shocked at how instinctive, smart and technically sound he is. Displaying great competitiveness on every snap, Carradine made a ton of plays through sheer effort and hustle chasing down ball carriers 10+ yards down the field. Although he was often the last defensive linemen moving at the snap, he was by far the most productive of Florida State's defensive linemen in the five games evaluated - He was involved in 1 play out of every 7.31 snaps which is a rare ratio and usually that of a Top Five Overall Pick. In the end, Carradine's play on the field no doubt warrants being picked in the Top Ten, but the health of his right knee will be the primary determining factor in where he gets drafted. If his knee checks out and NFL medical personnel feel that he will return to 100% within a season or two then he will likely be a first round pick, but if there are any medical questions he will slide into the second round. I believe that while he will likely need a season to get back to 100%, by the 2014 season he will be a starting defensive end and eventually a high end starter.
|
|
| 20 |
Matt Barkley QB, Southern California |
6-2 |
230 |
8.0 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - As fundamentally sound quarterback, Barkley is able to consistently play to the limits of his ability. Smooth dropping back to pass, his excellent footwork enables him to plant and drive off back foot to make quick and accurate throws on quick hitting passes. This great technique contributes to Barkley being the most accurate passer of the top quarterbacks in this year's draft class. Not only accurate on short/intermediate passes, Barkley has great touch on deep throws. Having played in USC's pro style offense, Barkley is well versed in making the pre-snap read, making the correct checks and setting the protection. Unlike many college quarterbacks, Barkley uses shoulder fakes and his eyes to move defenders and open up receivers easily and then can get rid of the ball quickly and accurately to the receiver he opened up. Perhaps his best trait is that he does not panic under pressure and will not force passes into bad spots to avoid sacks. He consistently shows a willingness to throw the ball away.
WEAKNESSES - Barkley lacks elite physical talent. While he has a good enough arm to make all the necessary NFL throws, he lacks a premier arm and will have some issues in bad weather and windy conditions. Although he can move and slide well to avoid pressure in the pocket, he is not a top athlete and is not going to make plays scrambling with the ball. He has been playing with a lot of elite offensive weapons at USC and has not dominated consistently, which raises concerns in my eyes about how he will do when his team is equal in talent to the opponent. Additionally, despite all the talent on offense he struggled to consistently convert key third and fourth downs into first downs to keep drives alive.
SUMMARY - The rare college quarterback who never redshirted and started four years for one of the premier football programs in the country, Barkley has experienced as much pressure as any college quarterback in recent memory. While many expected him to come out early for the 2012 NFL Draft, barkley impressed many in the NFL by staying in school to try and finish what he started despite USC's sanctions. After a disappointing senior season where USC failed to achieve the great success many expected, Barkley has shown toughness, composure and grit trying to lead the team. Not a premier physical talent, he will be downgraded by some teams because there are questions about his ability to pass effectively in bad weather/windy conditions. Overall, Barkley is a much better NFL prospect than many say he is and I feel there are a lot of similarities between him coming out of USC and Drew Brees when he came out of Purdue. Based on Barkley's ability to step in and be a productive starter at USC as a true freshman, I think he will be ready to handle starting as a rookie in the NFL. I believe that Barkley will end up being a good starting quarterback in the NFL, but will need to improve his ability to convert key downs to extend drives to become better than an average NFL starter.
|