|
| 01 |
Tyler Eifert TE, Notre Dame |
6-6 |
251 |
8.1 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Eifert has the height and bulk NFL teams love for the TE position. He is a very smooth athlete capable of running precise route and creating natural separation off his breaks against LBs playing man coverage. He is a physical, explosive player with the ball in the air that consistently demonstrates the ability to adjust his body and high point the ball to secure catches in traffic while absorbing heavy hits. He is a competitive runner after the catch and a willing blocker that demonstrates natural lower body flexibility and foot quickness.
WEAKNESSES - While a fluid athlete, Eifert lacks explosive vertical speed and has to rely on his size, physicality and competitiveness to create separation against defensive backs. While a competitive blocker, he tends to bend at the waist instead of his knees, which causes him to fall off blockers early in space. Despite showing natural fluidity while making cuts he has a tendency to get too high on his breaks which limits his ability to accelerate and create consistent separation.
SUMMARY - Tyler Eifert is an impressive physical specimen that is ready to make an instant impact in the NFL. He has the size, fluidity and physicality to run strong routes and create consistent separation against LBs, and possesses the body control to adjust to balls outside of his frame. He has soft hands that allow him to pluck the ball away from his body naturally, and consistently wins 50/50 balls because of his explosive leaping ability and strength at the POA. While he is an inconsistent blocker because of his tendency to get too far out front of himself and lose his balance, he is a willing combatant at the LOS and shows the ability to use his size and natural quickness to get his feet around and seal his man out when playing in-line. Eifert is a matchup nightmare capable of playing in-line or flexed out in the slot and is ready to make huge plays in the passing game for whichever team drafts him in the 1st round.
|
|
| 02 |
Gavin Escobar TE, San Diego State |
6-6 |
255 |
8.05 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - There isn't a more natural pass-catcher at the position than Escobar. He has super-long arms and big hands, and he consistently plucks the ball away from his frame. He is a graceful athlete with a long stride, and his future is bright because of his ability to stretch the field and go up to get the ball. He has surprising quickness and can quickly separate from defensive backs as he gets out of his break. Escobar has deceptive ability to run away from defenders and is a very polished route runner, using his head and shoulders to sell fakes.
WEAKNESSES - Escobar is not a great blocker who is going to overpower defenders in the in-line blocking game. He does a better job using his body to wall off a defender, but it is an area where he needs to improve if he is going to help his teammates. He might end up being a good blocker with some time in an NFL strength and training program, as he lacks the strength to line up and push players around the field.
SUMMARY - Gavin Escobar comes into the NFL at a perfect time for his set of skills. Teams are using the hybrid tight end to stretch the field with their length, long arms and ability to wall off defenders because of the size of their bodies. Escobar brings all of these skills to the NFL table and more as he has great hands and catches everything that is thrown at him. He consistently catches the ball away from his body, making it more difficult for defenses to cover him. He shows explosion in and out of his breaks, and he eats up cushion quickly when lined up from the slot. Linebackers can't stay with him because of his movement ability, and cornerbacks can't stay with him because of his size. His ability to run after the catch is truly underrated because he can move laterally and avoid the tackler, and then run into open space. He consistently can locate the ball, make an adjustment with his body and make the catch. This might be Escobar's best trait, and his biggest asset going forward. He makes tough catches look easy and will make a quarterback more accurate with his huge catching radius. He has incredible hands, and makes contested catches all over the field. Escobar is going to present significant challenges to NFL defenses because of his ability to play jump ball in the red zone and down the seam. If he can improve in the blocking area, he will be the complete package and a rock star in the NFL. He warrants consideration in the middle of Round 1, and should be in consideration to be the first tight end off the board in April.
|
|
| 03 |
Vance McDonald TE, Rice |
6-5 |
260 |
7.3 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - He has a wide, thick build with very good arm length and big hands to consider for the position at the NFL level. McDonald is a good overall athlete with solid agility, body control and balance in his play. At Rice, he was a highly productive receiver in the underneath to middle area of the field, showing a big wing-span and making for a big target for his quarterback. He aligned in multiple positions within his college scheme, but mainly out of the slot. He does a nice job of creating separation out of his breaks with good, sudden movements to gain separation from his defender. When he gets a free release, he eats up the cushion immediately and gets on top of the defense quickly. He has not been used as an in-line blocker but more out of the slot, but he is a very willing blocker who does a very nice job of blocking out in space. He is a tough competitor with a big body and he plays an aggressive brand of football. He has great functional strength as shown by the 31 repetitions he benched at the combine. McDonald was also the team's long snapper and gives added value on special teams.
WEAKNESSES - He has above average height with only average long speed and explosiveness in his movements. He is not a player with great lateral agility and isn't overly quick in short areas. While he looks comfortable catching the ball, there are times when his hands look out of sorts and he fights the ball through the catch, and this shows up almost every game. He doesn't catch the ball at its highest point and doesn't make full use of his long arms because of it. McDonald's size is his greatest route running strength as he isn't quick out of his breaks, but the combination of size and quickness he does have is enough to get the job done. He is not a vertical threat and lacks elusiveness in his run-after-catch ability. He is an inconsistent in-line blocker, but he was rarely used this way in the Rice offense and he does a nice job of blocking out in space.
SUMMARY - Rice's Vance McDonald is a big tight end with very good athletic traits with an intriguing NFL future. McDonald is a one-speed player who is fast, but not quick to change directions or out of his breaks as a route runner. He needs a step or two to get up to full speed and can surprise cornerbacks by eating up cushion quickly to run past them. McDonald is a very good route runner as he finds a way to get open, but he lacks short area quickness to separate from defenders and does it using his big body. He is a very smart route runner who understands the system he plays in, and exploits defenses with his understanding of soft areas in zone coverage. McDonald tends to fight the ball at times and can have inconsistent hands that cause him to drop the ball. While McDonald is fast, he possesses one speed and if defenses can disrupt his momentum, he will struggle to finish the route. He isn't elusive and won't hit the homerun, but he will move the chains because of his ability to put his head down and run through contact. At Rice, he wasn't used as an in-line blocker but he was good out in space, bullying the smaller players he went against. He looks to be a very willing blocker but teams will have to develop him from an in-line perspective. McDonald was used in a variety of ways at Rice, and he could be seen lining up out wide, or taking a hand-off and running a tight end reverse. However, he was lined up in a majority of the time out of the slot and that's where he is best suited in the NFL. He has been a very productive tight end in college because of his mismatch ability and his size/speed combination. He also can contribute early on special teams and it gives added value to his selection. McDonald warrants consideration starting in the middle-to-late part of the second-round.
|
|
| 04 |
Zach Ertz TE, Stanford |
6-6 |
252 |
7.0 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Zach Ertz is an excellent athlete who has the ability to run past LB's in the middle of the field. He is a build-up speed type of player with a long stride. Ertz can create mismatches because of his size/speed combination, and is effective enough while blocking that he should not come off of the field. He shows very soft, natural hands and looks comfortable making catches while adjusting to the ball, and he will fight for the ball when contested. Ertz is a solid route runner who gets open using his big body to box out defenders. He is big enough to run through arm tackles and is a weapon to gain yards physically. He is an efficient route runner with no wasted motion. He gets off the line quickly and finds soft spots in zone coverage to sit in. He looks at his best running the slant from the outside receiver position. Stanford lines him up everywhere on offense to create mismatches. He is a willing blocker and needs help from NFL coaching to improve in this area. Ertz is a tough, competitive football player who plays a gritty brand of football.
WEAKNESSES - Ertz is not a sudden athlete who can change direction easily, and he isn't explosive athletically. He is a one speed athlete who needs a few steps to build up his speed. While he catches the ball naturally, he needs to find more consistency as he will drop the ball here and there. Ertz lacks elite short area quickness but has enough to find ways to get open. He isn't a home run hitter, lacking long speed and the elusiveness to make defenders miss in the open field. He looks like a plodding pass catcher without any elite traits. NFL teams will have to be creative with him on offense as he looks better releasing uncovered because he can struggle with a jam at the line of scrimmage. While willing, Ertz is not technically sound as a blocker and gives up his man too often. He uses his big body to his advantage by walling off defenders, but he isn't a physical blocker and needs to improve if teams are to use him as an in-line blocking TE.
SUMMARY - Stanford's Zach Ertz is a natural pass catching tight end that possesses good athletic traits, but there isn't anything that is elite from an athletic perspective. He has good speed, but he needs a few steps to build up to it, and he lacks a second gear. Ertz is a very good route runner as he finds a way to get open, but he lacks short area quickness to separate from defenders. He is a very smart route runner who understands the system he plays in, and exploits defenses with his understanding of soft areas in zone coverage and route concepts. He tracks and locates the ball well, and will fight for it when it is challenged. He displays soft hands and is a fairly reliable pass catcher. While he doesn't possess great speed, he will gain yards after the catch because of his willingness to run through contact and is a player who will be tough to bring down. Ertz is not elusive and will most likely be a very good tight end that will move the chains in the NFL. He is not a strong blocker as his size would indicate, as he doesn't stick to his blocking assignments long enough, but he does an average job of making defenders run around him to get to the ball carrier. He is a willing blocker and could improve dramatically in this area with good NFL coaching. He is highly competitive and plays a tough brand of football. Ertz has been lined up all over the field in the Stanford offense, from split out wide to fullback, and he has very good versatility from a position perspective. He is a very productive tight end without elite athletic tools, flashing generally average speed and big play ability. However, he has proven to be a reliable pass catcher who makes plays with his intelligence and system awareness. He warrants consideration starting right away in the third-round because of his high level of production at Stanford.
|
|
| 05 |
Matt Furstenburg TE, Maryland |
6-4 |
245 |
6.5 J |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Quick off the ball and into route, Furstenburg can get behind LOS defender and has the speed to get separation down the seam. Possessing good body control, flexibility and agility make it easy for him to get in and out of cuts quickly to run sharp/precise routes. It is obvious from how he adjusts his routes to become "hot" receiver versus blitzes that he is a smart player who studies film to be prepared. Also blessed with good vision and awareness, he is able to consistently identify open spots in the defense to sit down in. Not the type of receiver who waits for the pass to get to him, he attacks it with his hands and catches the ball cleanly every time. He is quick tucking the ball away after the catch and starts up the field fast. He is a quicker than fast runner who after the catch who runs hard with the ball and can run through hits and grab tackles to gain yards after contact. His initial quickness helps him make contact quickly on side/angle in-line run blocks and he is usually able to tie up and seal man out of the play. He gives a good effort and uses good footwork in pass protection.
WEAKNESSES - There is not much to critique when it comes to the receiving side of Furstenburg's game. While he has the speed to get separation on deep seam routes, he does not show the same speed to run away from defenders to make big plays after the catch. While his effort is always there as an in-line run blocker, he will leave his feet behind at times and ends up bending at the waist, leaning and ducking his head, which leads to him losing the block. While his effort and feet are good in pass pro, he does not uses his hands well and can be defeated too easily by aggressive pass rushers. He is not a big tight end and will always have some issues as a blocker due to the size differential.
SUMMARY - It was readily apparent that Furstenburg was amongst the best players at the Texas Versus The Nation Game from the first practice as he clearly was more athletic and polsihed than most of the players there. While his lack of ideal bulk/weight will likely always be an issue when he blocks, his athleticism, speed and receiving skills make him a very good prospect. Fifteen or twenty years ago he would likely have been viewed as a one-dimensional, under-sized tight end with little value, but in today's NFL his receiving skills and athleticism should enable him to contribute catching passes as a rookie and eventually to him becoming a versatile and productive receiving weapon in his team's offense. I do not anticipate Furstenburg being drafted as highly as I have him rated, but I believe that within a season it will be clear why I have such a good grade on him. I think he will become a very productive pass catcher in the NFL and could be a star if he goes to a team with an offensive coordinator who is good at using versatile receiving weapons like him.
|
|
| 06 |
Jordan Reed TE, Florida |
6-3 |
243 |
6.2 J |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Reed is a smooth, fluid athlete capable of making tight cuts when given a free release on his breaks. He displays good acceleration and burst off the LOS, which allows him to consistently beat LBs vertically. He plucks the ball naturally away from his body, and shows the ability to high point balls in traffic as well as adjust to off target throws. After the catch, he is extremely competitive, and flashes not only the power to run through tackles but the foot quicks to elude defenders in space. He is also a competitive blocker, as he fights to the whistle despite strength limitations and poor technique. While he clearly needs to add weight to his frame he is solidly built and should be able to pack on another 15-20 lbs.
WEAKNESSES - Reed is a classic tweener that lacks the speed to play WR and the natural power and strength to be an in-line TE. When blocking he tends to bend at the waist and get overextended, causing him to fall off blocks early. His poor strength at the POA is also a concern when blocking, but is even more evident when facing physical coverage, as he struggles to get clean releases off jams. He must learn to better use his hands to set defenders and protect his frame against press coverage, and fight harder to get out of his breaks and stay on his line.
SUMMARY - Jordan Reed was a difficult player to evaluate because he does not have a natural position at the next level. He does not have the power to block in-line and consistently falls off blocks early because of poor base and leverage. Although he is a highly effective receiver when he isn't challenged off the LOS, he lacks the speed needed to play on the outside and is not likely to transition to WR. All this being said, he is a smooth route runner with excellent burst when given a free release, and he is a highly competitive runner after the catch. He also displays outstanding hands, as he consistently plucks the ball away from his body, and has the leaping ability and body control to go get off target throws. He is likely to have a role at the next level similar to that of fellow former Gator Aaron Hernandez, as he is most effective when allowed to play in space away from the jam and away from in-line blocking assignments. Because today's NFL is so predicated on creating mismatches in the passing game, Reed is worth a day two selection for a team willing to line him up off the LOS.
|
|
| 07 |
Dion Sims TE, Michigan State |
6-5 |
285 |
6.0 E |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - To say that Sims "looks the part of an NFL TE" would be a drastic under-statement as he has the size and physique that makes NFL teams drool. Once he gets moving at the snap, Sims accelerates to full speed quickly and has better than expected speed down for a big TE. Soft, natural hands combine with Sims' body control and coordination so that he can twist and adjust to make tough catches with remarkable ease. He shows no hesitation catching passes heading into traffic and can get up to win jump ball battles over defenders. While he could run more aggressively after the catch, Sims strength and athleticism help him to run through hits and arm/grab tackles to gain yards after contact. He has the size and natural strength to be a dominating blocker when he gives the effort and uses good technique.
WEAKNESSES - Sims without question frustrates with his lack of intensity and aggressiveness. For a TE with his size and natural strength, Sims is a below average blocker due to a lack of consistent effort. He often gets upright at the snap on run blocks and does not aggressively go get man. Rather he ends up just trying to get in the way as a blocker and is not consistently effective. For such a smooth athlete with good playing speed, Sims lack of explosiveness off the ball hinders his ability to get off the ball fast or get separation down the seam. Much more of a smooth route runner, Sims lacks a burst out of his cuts to get separation from NFL linebackers in man coverage.
SUMMARY - After a junior season when he was not as dominant as was expected, Sims surprised many when he declared for the Draft. There has never been any doubt about Sims talent, but his lack of intensity/aggressively definitely limits his overall production; especially as a blocker and runner after the catch. Based on his film Sims was viewed as a likely third round pick, but after an outstanding Pro Day performance where he looked like "a first round pick" according to NFL sources in attendance, Sims' stock is definitely on the rise. Overall, the most likely scenario is that Sims will be a solid receiving tight end who frustrates coaches with his inconsistent blocking and lack of intensity/aggressiveness. However, if his coaches can motivate him to crank things up he has the talent to be an impact tight end who changes games as a receiver and blocker.
|
|
| 08 |
Mychal Rivera TE, Tennessee |
6-3 |
244 |
5.9 J |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - While not a big tight end, Rivera has still been a productive side/angle blocker on in-line run blocks. He is quick to get off the ball and fires into inside shaded defender to pin him inside on outside runs. The same quickness off the ball he shows on in-line blocks, helps Rivera to get in routes quickly and to the second level with ease on blocks in space. It looks easy for Rivera to lock on and maintain blocks on linebackers on the second level because he can bend knees to block with good base and has natural balance to keep feet. Experience lining up as an in-line tight end, move H-back, fullback and split out in the slot shows Rivera's versatility and football smarts. Rivera has deceptive speed running routes, is sharp out of his cuts and does an excellent job of getting his head and hands around quickly to catch passes that get on top of him fast. Good body control, coordination and soft hands are what have allowed Rivera to make tough catches seem routine. He is quick to get started up the field after the catch and is a competitive runner who fights for every last yard. Even though he does not break many tackles, he does run through a number of attempted grab tackles and hits to gain yards after contact.
WEAKNESSES - Despite his college production and effort making good side/angle blocks in college, his lack of bulk/weight will hinder his ability to carry this production over in the NFL. Additionally, he has always been less effective blocking head-up defenders and will have even more trouble blocking the bigger and stronger defensive ends in the NFL. "Tweener" is an apt description of Rivera as he lacks the size to be a true in-line tight end and the explosiveness and top end speed to be an impact receiving tight end that is so "in" now. Occasionally, Rivera gets upright when running routes and is much less effective getting in and out of his cuts when he does.
SUMMARY - A good college tight end, Rivera will find it hard to be as productive in the NFL. While I believe that Rivera will have a hard time becoming an impact player in the NFL, I am confident that his receiving skills combined with his ability to block well in space and his positional versatility should allow him to carve out a role as a versatile backup player. If he were to go to a team with an offensive coach who is creative he could be used in a variety of roles to take advantage of his ability make plays catching passes and blocking effectively out in space. When I watch Rivera play I see some similarities to current Texans' backup tight end James Casey and the Broncos Joel Dressen. Overall, I doubt Rivera will be a high draft pick, but somewhere in the fourth or fifth round a team like San Diego, New England or Philadelphia may take a gamble on him as he has many of the tools to be a versatile, contributing team member who can be used like a chess piece and aligned in many different spots. .
|
|
| 09 |
Joseph Fauria TE, UCLA |
6-7 |
255 |
5.9 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Fauria has ideal height, length and bulk for the position at the NFL level. He is quick off the LOS which allows him to immediately put pressure on LBs in coverage. He has the ability to change speeds as well as get physical on his breaks, allowing him to run tight routes and create separation. His best asset is his ball skills, as he consistently wins 50/50 balls because of his ability to elevate and use his frame to shield defenders from the ball, as well as utilize his strong hands to consistently pluck balls away from his frame and hold on while absorbing punishment. He flashes the ability to block with power and leverage, and can seal his man out and sustain 2nd level blocks.
WEAKNESSES - Although Fauria displays good short area quickness and agility, he is not an explosive athlete and must rely on sound route-running in order to create separation. He lacks the speed to consistently stretch defenses over the top and is an elusive runner with the ball in his hands. While he is physically capable of being an effective blocker both in-line and out in space, he is not consistently physical and will at times fall off blocks early.
SUMMARY - Joseph Fauria is not being mentioned in the same breath as some of the top TEs in this draft class, but he clearly has the tools to become a productive NFL player. While not an explosive or elusive athlete, he does display solid short area quickness and smooth, savvy route running ability, which allows him to gain separation on his breaks. Once the ball is in the air he is a nightmare for LBs and DBs to match up with, as he high-points the ball and uses his huge frame and catching radius to consistently win contested balls. He clearly has the flexibility and strength to be an effective blocker, but must be more consistent with his level of competitiveness. The depth of this year's TE class is likely to drop Fauria to day three, but he has starter's upside at the next level because of his size, strength and ball skills.
|
|
| 10 |
Levine Toilolo TE, Stanford |
6-8 |
265 |
5.6 I |
Full Scouting Report |
|
Scouting Report:
STRENGTHS - Toilolo is a huge target for a quarterback as a receiver in the red zone due to his tremendous height. He shows soft hands and the ability to track and locate the ball and fight for it in traffic. At 6'8" tall, he has a natural advantage to go up and get the ball. He has enough speed to threaten the middle of the field and stretch the seam, and some quickness to gain separation from linebackers. He shows good footwork and hand usage to get off the line of scrimmage and into his routes and does a nice job settling into open pockets of the zone. Toilolo shows a nice burst when given a free release and can really eat up cushion with the long strides. He is an excellent blocker, using his long arms to create space and keep defenders at bay.
WEAKNESSES - Toilolo isn't an elite athlete with the natural speed to run away from a defense. He is a versatile player who can be an impact blocker as an in-line tight end, or a nice possession type tight end lined up out of the slot. He will have the occasional drop and concentration and focus needs to be improved. At times, he looks robotic while catching the ball and he needs to become more natural in this area. He has a very long stride and needs a step or two to get up to speed, but it doesn't hurt him as a route runner. He doesn't have great explosion out of his breaks and isn't going to wow with his ability to get open, but he is so big that he can "block out the sun" and keep defenders away from the ball with his long arms. There is no real elusiveness to his game as he is a straight-line runner with very little lateral agility. Teams like to jam him, trying to get him restarted because it takes a little time to get going again. He tore his ACL in 2010 but appears fully recovered from the injury.
SUMMARY - Toilolo has some very interesting potential going forward. He is a huge target with a massive catching radius which makes him an instant red zone threat. He was outperformed by Coby Fleener in 2012 and again in 2013 by Zach Ertz, but the former might be as over rated as Tolilolo is under rated. He can make plays down the seam and in the red zone with his route running abilities. For such a large player, he does a nice job of separating to get open in soft areas of the zone. He presents a mismatch problem for defensive backs because of the sheer size and again for linebackers because of his quickness. If he can improve his ability to catch the ball, he could be a real nice asset in the NFL for an offense looking for a player who can move the chains and bring a threat in the red zone. He is a very good blocker and can help immediately as an in-line blocker, using his long arms and core strength to wall off defenders. There isn't much elusiveness in his game as he is a straight-line runner once he has the ball in his hands, but he can help in a variety of ways. Toilolo is an under rated tight end prospect coming out of the pro-style offense that Stanford runs, and with a little seasoning he could develop into a nice player in the NFL. He warrants fourth-round consideration for a team looking for a massive target that can impact an offense in several ways.
|