FROM WES BUNTING:
You have to love the second day of the draft, where prospects from all walks of life come off the board with the same goal, making an NFL roster. Here are some of my initial impressions from day two of the draft.
I love what the Chicago Bears did. DT Jarron Gilbert is an ideal three-technique guy who can explode off the ball and penetrate into the backfield. While CB D.J. Moore fell because of his lack of speed, he will likely end up developing into a starter for Chicago in the coming years.
The Chiefs’ third round pick, DE Alex Magee, was an interesting choice because they also drafted DE Tyson Jackson with the third overall pick. Magee, like Jackson, is best suited to play the five-technique defensive end spot, so where does that leave 2008 first-round pick DL Glenn Dorsey? I don’t think Dorsey is a good fit in the Chiefs’ new hybrid 3-4 scheme.

I love the Dolphins’ pick of WR Patrick Turner in the third round. Miami needed a big, physical possession-type wideout, and Turner will be a complement to WR Ted Ginn Jr. at the next level. Turner needs a burner across from him to open up the field, but I can see him doing a nice job working the middle and picking up key first downs for Miami in the future.
In my opinion, the Steelers got the draft’s top vertical threat, WR Mike Wallace. Pittsburgh lost WR Nate Washington this offseason via free agency, and I see Wallace filling a similar role in the Steelers’ offense.
The Seahawks lost their sultan of slot this offseason, WR Bobby Engram, but they may have found a replacement in the form of fellow Penn State wideout Deon Butler. Butler has been flying up draft boards the past month and is a guy who I think has the makings of a top slot receiver at the next level.
Dallas had a wealth of picks on the second day and got one of the most intriguing quarterbacks in the draft, Texas A&M’s Stephen McGee. He may be a year of two away, but McGee has all the tools and could have a career similar to that of current Cowboys QB Tony Romo.

I absolutely love what Jacksonville did throughout the draft by rebuilding their offensive line. However, the guy who could have the biggest impact next season is WR Mike Thomas. He, like Deon Butler, has the makings of a big time slot receiver. Thomas knows how to beat press and can consistently gain initial separation underneath.
The one sleeper I’ve been touting for weeks is Western Ontario product DT Vaughn Martin. Martin is a massive interior defensive lineman who possesses rare athleticism for a guy his size. He needs some time to mature but could be the heir apparent to NT Jamal Williams in the Chargers’ 3-4 defense.
I still can’t believe TE Shawn Nelson lasted all the way until the fourth round, but he may be the biggest value pick in the entire draft. Nelson is exactly what the Bills need in the passing game. He has an ability to make plays down the seam and create mismatches all over the field. I expect him to become an impact tight end at the next level.
The Colts did a nice job finding fits for their schemes on both sides of the ball with their second-day picks. Indianapolis needed to add more girth inside on defense, and DT Terrance Taylor is a guy who is tough to move off the ball. And WR Austin Collie isn’t a great athlete, but he’s a smart, gifted route runner who will be an ideal fit in the Colts’ precision offense.
One point that has gone virtually unnoticed is that fact the Browns traded for QB Brett Ratliff on day one of the draft. Ratliff not only knows head coach Eric Mangini but also the Cleveland offense, and I think he has all the tools to develop into an NFL starting quarterback. In what was one of the weakest quarterback draft classes in years, did the Browns secretly get their franchise quarterback in the 2009 draft? For the record, I would take Ratliff over QB Josh Freeman any day.
Offensive linemen Jamon Meredith (Green Bay Packers) and Duke Robinson (Carolina Panthers) went back to back in the fifth round after sitting around a lot longer than most thought they would. Both prospects were considered second/third-round picks, but I think they’re good fits in their new offenses and have the ability to mature into starters during the early parts of their careers.

Broncos sixth-round pick QB Tom Brandstater will grab all the headlines and instantly draw unrealistic Tom Brady comparisons. However, if I had to put my money on a late-round QB to find his way in the NFL, it’s Mike Teel to Seattle. The Rutgers product is an ideal fit in the Seahawks’ west coast offense and should be able to sit back, learn and develop under current QB Matt Hasselbeck. A great fit for both Teel and the Seahawks in the sixth round.
On film study alone, I considered the Browns’ sixth round pick, CB Coye Francies, a top-10 corner in the draft. However, his character concerns and slower than anticipated 40 time knocked him down some draft boards this weekend. Now, if he can leave the past behind him, I think Francies has the length, closing speed and footwork to mature into a starting corner in the near future.
Finally, speaking of character concerns, if you really think the Bengals are changing their viewpoint on the value of a prospect’s character, look no further than this draft. Not only are there slight concerns with their first two picks, OT Andre Smith and ILB Rey Maualuga, but their sixth-round pick, RB Bernard Scott, has a track record second to none. Scott was kicked off his high school football team and was also dismissed from Central Arkansas for hitting a coach. I’m not saying this is a bad draft class for the Bengals, just pointing out the lack of stock they still put into character.
Nice breakdown, Wes -
Kansas City HC Todd Haley said that they were gonna be plugging Dorsey into the nose -
Love the Turner call 8)- Remember us talking about Turner and John Nalbone (Miami 5th round pick)?
I liked Brandstater quite a bit before the draft - Even moreso now with the quarterbacks in front of him at Denver -
I spoke about Lardarius Webb some in an earlier column of yours - Loved seeing his rise - Watch out for that kid in Baltimor - He's a baller -
Both Colts tackles should impact - The kid from USC and Taylor - They wanted to get bigger on their front 7 and did -
Well Sean Smith ended up in Miami after all - Welcome to the quarters Mr Smith -
Sorry about your boy Nelson, Wes...it happens, just look a my guy Everette Brown - ;) At least both players went to teams where they can flourish as players -
Nelson can work the middle of the field with Owens and Evans out wide taking safeties deep -
The only early round front seven defensive picks by the Panthers over the past decade have been Julius Peppers, Kris Jenkins, Dan Morgan, Will Witherspoon and Jon Beason - I think those guys doing the drafting down there know a little something about the front 7 - A first round pick next year for my guy Brown - I like it -:)
I've been looking for an UFA streamer, KFFL used to be good about that but google gave me a goose egg for anything time relevant...
How is it that Mitch King goes undrafted? At the very least he could provide a team with some depth on the d-line.
Murder, This could be construed as a lot of work but NFL.com has a pretty good running tally of drafted and undrafted players listed alphabetically here -
http://www.nfl.com/draft/2009/tracker#dt-tabs:dt-by-name
What in god's name happened to Mitch King this weekend?
Mr. Murder:
KFFL seems fine to me, just check here:http://www.kffl.com/hotw/nfl
Bill Parcells is my uncle:
I was very sad when my Bills passed on Brown in the second round. Teaming Maybin and Brown would have been worthwhile and great value IMHO.
Why we took a CB to convert to free safety I do not understand. A bit early in the second round for that.
I love the picks of my Seahawks (I'm probalby the lone Italian Seahawks fan...) They have picked three starters with their first 3 picks, and the trade with the Broncos was great, it could translate in a really high pick. They've trusted Matt's back, but picked Teel that could develope in a great qb for the future (I watched some Rutgers games on ESPN America and I really liked him). Three questions: first, do you think that Nick Reed could move to olb and in a year or two give them some production there? second, what's happened with Frantz Joseph? he's a two down LB, but to go undrafted was a bit of shock. third, is Graham Harrell that bad?
Richter,
Seems I wasn't overvaluing Brace at 47 afterall....I decided to move Gilbert into my mock (in place of Brace) as he seemed like the ideal 3-4 DE...... I should have stuck with my gut instinct on Brace all along....
Wes:
I told you that you were abnormally high on Shawn Smith. I also told you that Brandon Tate was a lot higher on people's boards than the 4th round. Shawn Nelson? Yup, you were crazy about that guy...that makes one of you. I think your aseessment of Vaughn Martin was spot-on...I wish that Packers would have nabbed him. Also, you were right about Meredith. He did drop like a lead weight. Oh well, the NFL's loss was the Packers' gain. All-in-all? Great work this year. Sorry to nitpick, but you are very good at what you do...I can't resist.
try www.gbnreport.com for UFA's. they do a pretty decent job of it for a small site.
Dan, Yeah I was very surprised to see Brown drop past all those teams -
:) Carolina sure jumped right in front of the Phins, Giants, Texans, Pats and Broncos to go get him - They must have felt one of those teams were on him -
I do like Gil's kid Jairus Byrd quite a bit though - And I wouldn't limit him soley to the free safety position - I spoke about his closing speed earlier in here in one of Wes' columns - Miami scouted him heavily for their quarters, which puts heavy emphasis on the corners ability to contain his man on posts and fades - His timed speed is a misnomer -
Your Bills still had an outstanding draft in my view - But the pairing of Maybin and Brown sure would have been nice, as you said -
Bob, You might wanna let Sean Smith and Shawn Nelson strap on a jock for a couple years before calling Wes out on either of them - Remember those were Wes rankings of the players - I didn't see either player listed in round one of the final NFP mock draft - ;)
WES....Where's the love for Ramses Barden?!?! The dude is HUGE.
Ricther,
Garry Beckwith was grabbed as a UDFA by the Chargers. The Chargers met with him twice and were high on him. I thought they would grab him in the middle of the draft. Scout.com interviewed him and he said teams were scared off by his history of knee injuries. He struggled last year because he had arthroscopic knee surgery in Sep 2008. He says he's healthy and ready to make an impact. I hope so. ILB is one of the Chargers weaknesses that wasn't addressed in the draft.
| powered by TheSeats.com |
Vegas police say insufficient...
Tough to imagine him getting a...
Team hires two strength coaches
But new offensive coordinator...
Wide receiver gets a look
Apr 26, 2009
08:15 PM
What happened to your guy Darry Beckwith, Wes? I know you were high on him as a value guy, while I didn't like him, and he went undrafted. Do you think he'll still catch on with a team somewhere?