FROM MICHAEL LOMBARDI:
For me, running backs should be broken down into categories specifying the skill levels they perform best. For example, each category carries a specific role, and it’s important for the back to fit into the offense. You don’t want to bring a zone back into a man scheme run team. The pieces have to fit properly.
A player graded high here must be able to catch, run and block. We still have the nickel back position -- a back who plays in passing downs, smaller good blocker, who can catch the ball. To be graded high, this player must score a 7 for hands and have enough intelligence to handle all sub-protections. The nickel back must dominate his position in college.
Running Back Reminders:
1. Does he make yards after first contact? He must win in this phase in college. How many yards does he get from the offensive line? Great backs finish.
2. Finish does not mean long runs all the time. Hard to have long runs in the NFL (50-plus yards) without making a person miss, or breaking a tackle.
3. Must be able to make plays when the play breaks down. Great players make great plays. We need more than what it is blocked for.
4. Running back is an instinctive position, hard to train good runners. Must have instincts.
5. Must protect the ball. How many fumbles in his career? What hand does he carry the ball in? Does he change hands? Did he fumble in HS?
6. Durable after 10 carries? After 20? After 30? What kind of hits does he take? What does he do in the spring? Are they live to tackle?
7. First-quarter production compared to fourth-quarter production.
8. Who does he gain his yards against? What rankings does the opponent have in run defenses?
9. Can he run our running plays? Must know our style of running. Denver is different than Minnesota.
10. Role on third down? Role in the kicking game? Can he catch the ball down the field? What does his passing tree look like?
11. Great backs are great in high school -- did he win the state rushing title?
12. Is he a point-of-entry back? Or can he redirect at the line? Point-of-entry backs are limited in their run play selection (Tyrone Wheatley).
13. Whom does he block in protection? The OLB? The safety? We need to know “whom” he can block, as much as if he can block. Define the “whom.”
14. Does he know protections? How many do they have? What kind of protections do they use? Any scat protections used?
15. What kind of blocker is he? Low block? Cut in hole? Side-stepper? Define how he does it.
16. Fullback position is a dying breed in this league. Can the big halfback play FB?
17. Can the FB run the wheel route and win? Can he catch the ball DOWN the field? Must have some versatility.
18. Is the FB good in the kicking game? He has to be to make the team.
19. Little backs have to protect if they want to be involved in the offense.
20. Must have players who can run the offense and not run plays. Hard to get the ball to players we need to run plays for. Works in September, dies in November.
THREE-DOWN BACKS
Name, team, age, height, weight, speed, year entered NFL, draft pos., agent
1. Derrick Ward, NY Giants, 28; 5-11, 233; 4.58; 2004; 7th round (235th overall); Peter Schaffer -- The only concern with this player is his injury history and durability. But he has the size, versatility and hands to play in any offense.
2. Darren Sproles, San Diego, 25; 5-6, 187; 4.52; 2005; 4th round (130th overall); Gary Wichard – He’s not a little back, just a shorter back. He needs to have the right back next to him, but he is so explosive and so field-changing that he will make more out of 20 plays than he does 30.
3. Lamont Jordan, New England, 30; 5-10, 233; 4.45; 2001; 2nd round (49th overall); Alvin Keels -- He still has very good skills, but he does have some injury and durability concerns. He went to the right team last year that can utilize his skill level.
4. Jason Wright, Cleveland, 26; 5-10, 210; 4.72; 2004; undrafted free agent; Michael McCartney -- He shows flashes of talent and running ability but has not had enough chances to be successful. He needs to go to the right team and get a chance first.
TWO-DOWN RUNNERS
1. Brandon Jacobs, NY Giants, 26; 6-4, 267; 4.64; 2005; 4th round (110th overall); Justin Schulman -- The best big back out there; he can control the game. Must run his runs, has to be led into the hole with clean surface and point of entry. He will get stronger as the game goes on and is best when there is a complement back with him.
2. Maurice Morris, Seattle, 28; 5-11, 202; 4.57; 2002; 2nd round (54th overall); Michael Sullivan -- This back has grown on me. He can run inside and is adequate in the passing game, but he has never seemed to get the playing time he deserves. He just keeps moving the chains.
3. Correll Buckhalter, Philadelphia, 30; 5-11, 222; 4.59; 2001; 4th round (121st overall); John Rickert – Age and injuries to his knee will keep this player from being a big-time money maker.
4. Cedric Benson, Cincinnati, 25; 5-10, 225; 4.61; 2005; 1st round (4th overall); Eugene Parker -- Was this his year, or was 2007? I tend to think it was junk yards this season and would be very reluctant to invest in him. He’s like a player who gets 10 rebounds a night but eight of them are off missed free throws. Benson has not convinced me.
5. Jesse Chatman, NY Jets, 29; 5-8, 215; 4.77; 2002; undrafted free agent; Brett Tessler -- This guy was a good back, but he is lazy and unmotivated. If he gets his mind right, he could help a team.
ZONE RUNNERS
1. Tatum Bell, Denver, 27; 5-11, 213; 4.41; 2004; 2nd round (41st overall); Kennard McGuire -- The one thing he can do is run nickel runs and make a play in a zone scheme. That’s all, but it’s something.
2. DeShaun Foster, San Francisco, 28; 6-0, 222; 4.5; 2002; 2nd round (34th overall); Joby Branion -- Talented but lacks the inside run scheme skills. If he goes to the right place where his carries are limited, he can make a few plays.
NICKEL BACKS
1. Michael Pittman, Denver, 33; 5-11, 218; 4.54; 1998; 4th round (95th overall); Drew Rosenhaus -- Age and injures make you worry, but he might be able to fill a role as a one-year player for a cheap price.
2. Dominic Rhodes, Indianapolis, 29; 5-9, 211; 4.61; 2001; undrafted free agent; Michael McCartney -- Has to go to the right team that can use his skills as a pass protector and runner. He has some talent left and is not as old as people think.
3. J.J. Arrington, Arizona, 25; 5-8, 214; 4.5; 2005; 2nd round (44th overall); John Rickert -- Return skills help him, but he must improve his protection skills.
4. Aveion Cason, Detroit, 29; 5-8, 191; 4.66; 2001; undrafted free agent; Ronald Slavin.
SPECIAL TEAMS
1. Aaron Stecker, New Orleans, 33; 5-9, 213; 4.61; 1999; undrafted free agent; Ronald Slavin.
1b and 8b must be kept in mind when evaluating all other traits for a RB. The golden rule is that you need to know what the OL is doing and what level is the D before assigning grades for all other game evaluations.
As I read about the Giants 2 RBS (Ward and Jacobs)and all the traits of the quintessential RB and FB, I thought of the former Giants (and UVa)tandem of Charles Way (FB) and Tiki Barber (RB). At their peaks, they are exactly what Mike is looking for at their respective positions. And whoever taught Mr. Lombardi that he should define the "whom" and not the "who" is to be congratulated.
I think Mike is right about the complementary back issue for Jacobs. I think the Giants decision needs to be partly determined by what they think of Ahmad Bradshaw and (maybe) Danny Ware. If they believe one of those guys can be a consistent complementary back and 3rd down receiver, you pay Jacobs. If you don't you might have to seriously consider choosing Ward because while Jacobs is good, he does wear down and is a poor pass receiver.
For all the oohs and aahs that go on when a guy like Darren McFadden or Chris Johnson run a 4.3 40, some of these guys have been successful without having great speed. Just goes to show that straight line speed isn't everything.
Sproles as a 3-down back? For the duration of the season? Seems a stretch to me. Plus, isn't he more valuable as a complimentary guy who also returns punts and kicks?
And I don't see much in Maurice Morris, he's the prom date who shows you just enough to make you think you are going to get a piece and then she gives you the Heisman.
I think what he means by 3-down back in this instance is a back that you can put on the field for any situation. Not necessarily a back you would use every single down but a back who is capable in any of the roles. The way the NFL has gone, there really aren't many every down backs anymore anyway.
So what you're saying is Ward is a better back then Jacobs? Yet we saw what the giants did in the playoffs this year with both of them. Jacobs ran the first Possession and did a pretty good job of it.
Ward took over for the 2nd possession the giants had and didn't do nearly as good as Jacobs did.
Jacobs 19 carries 92 yards.
0 passes.
Ward 12 carries 46 yards.
5 passes 24 yards.
While Ward makes up yard in the passing game, his yardage wasn't that great for that many carries. Still don't see how you can call him a 3 down back when his average for a playoff game in rushing was 3.8, and his long run was 14 yards. And take into account the Eagles were looking for the run. And Jacobs still ran over them.
Country,
Lombardi is saying that Ward is the best back that can play on all three downs. Jacobs is somewhat of a liability on pass/run downs because teams know he can't hurt them in the passing game.
I don't think anyone is arguing that Jacobs is less effective running the ball than Ward.
Jaccobs may have run over the Eagles but he was not able to take over the game and propel the Giants to victory with Eli struggling.
Another position the Raiders are deep with Fargas, McFadden & Bush. Nice to know we're deep at at least RB position including FB's.
As a Bengals fan I'd love to see them part ways with Benson, sign Derrick Ward and drafta RB in the second round (I'd prefer LeSean McCoy, but I'd settle for Shonn Greene or Donald Brown).
They've had bad luck with RB's lately (Chris Perry & Kenny Irons come to mind) so hopefully this is the year they can get a RB to build around.
C'MON PACKERS; PICK UP DOMINIC RHODES.
| powered by TheSeats.com |
Says he hasn't spoken to Lerner...
Running back has hip injury
Will miss Sunday's game vs. Atlanta
Two Titans combined for $17,500...
Heap has sore ribs, Ngata has...
Feb 05, 2009
09:05 PM
hi is actually Correll Buckhalter's girlfriend.