This past weekend, Cleveland Browns rookies were asked to take a road trip by head coach Eric Mangini — a 10-hour bus trip — to work his charity football camp in Hartford, Conn. It’s a story that’s continuing to drive national sports news. Today, I hope to make it clear that as a rookie you don’t have many options — whether it’s fair or not. Matt Bowen
This past weekend, Cleveland Browns rookies were asked to take a road trip by head coach Eric Mangini — a 10-hour bus trip — to work his charity football camp in Hartford, Conn. It’s a story that’s continuing to drive national sports news. Today, I hope to make it clear that as a rookie you don’t have many options — whether it’s fair or not.
Hitting the Road
Look, I think we can all agree that taking a 10-hour bus ride is no fun. Brutal might be a better word to describe it.
But that’s exactly what the Browns’ rookies did last weekend when they were asked by Mangini to go to a “voluntary” football camp — and we all know what “voluntary” means as an NFL rookie. Basically, get your butt on the bus if you want to be on my team.
Is it fair? Is it right? Absolutely not, folks. But if you’re a rookie, you don’t have an opinion, you don’t have a voice and you definitely don’t have a lot of choices when the head coach asks you to work at a charity football camp.
Now, I don’t know if there were no available seats on a plane, or if Mangini was just trying to see how his rookies would react (more likely the latter), but I can tell you that’s just how it is for a rookie at this level.

And it really isn’t up to the media to decide if this was the right thing to do because it is, in fact, Mangini’s football team.
And because of that, if I’m one of those Browns rookies, I shut my mouth, get on the bus and do what the boss says — if I want to play for that team. No, it’s probably not the best way to treat a young player trying to make a living playing football, but do we really feel sorry for these rookies because they had to make take a bus trip at the “request” of the head coach?
I don’t, and I’m going to tell you why.
The Rookie
As a rookie in this league — especially when you haven’t even made the team — it’s best to just do what you’re told.
During my first season in St. Louis, my rookie counterparts and I did a multiple of charity events that summer in which fans came out, asked where Marshall Faulk was and tried to figure out if I was a player or a member of the team’s marketing department. Sure, I got tired of it about 10 minutes into my first event, but they did serve a purpose to the community, and I was a rookie — what was I going to say?
“I don’t want to do it”?
Right, and I’m sure the first thing coach Mike Martz would have heard was how one of his rookies who was trying to make the team refused to do something he was asked. I can tell you this, my journalism degree from Iowa would have been put to use pretty quickly while I put together my resume after the Rams saw a rookie making his own rules.
Unfortunately, that’s just how it is for rookies, and these young players in Cleveland haven’t even been through their first training camp practice — where it will get a lot worse.
I don’t know what Mangini was thinking chartering a bus and making his rookies settle in for 20 hours on the road, and this story will continue to draw national attention. People will talk about “hazing” and all of that other nonsense — which they have every right to do.
But Mangini is the boss, and the rookies in Cleveland are just going to have to get used to that — if they want to make that team.
Is this something that Bill Walsh or Bill Belichick would have requested of his players? Especially the 10 hour bus ride as Mangenius flies a charter plane out to the event. Point being this is why they were/are great coaches/leaders of their organizations and Eric will be looking for a job in two years.
I can see this with an undrafted/later rounds draft pick but what if a 2nd RD DC said he didn't want to go? like he'd really be cut?
This sounds like some sort of stunt Hoodie would pull off. Are we sure he didn't learn this from him?!?!
Mangini is going to be a bust in Cleveland... This guy has nothing to work with and his players will shut it down by November if he keeps treating them like dogs..
"Man-Genius?"
Wouldn't trust Mangini with my pet rock, let alone a football team. I get the impression he thinks he's Belichick but he's not but that's his pseudo-identity.
There are better ways to improve your football team than a 10 hour bus ride.
A trip for the Cleveland Pranksters. Destination: Further.
*(Don't let Ray read this unless he's wearing shades and has a tight bandanna on.)
Well Sleepy,
Why didn't anyone say "no" then? These kids don't have a choice and although you might not get cut, you could see the bench for a while...
I can understand the power trip talk, but it's his team (for better or for worse). Where would we be if every move Lombardi made was held under a microscope? Think about the team building that occurs by having to sit next to somebody for 20 hours -- I'm not saying it's the BEST use of time, but I think everybody is pretty quick to jump on this story.
What is with these Belichick disciples? Mangini and McDaniels are complete ego-maniacs.
If Mangini hadn't, supposedly, had a poor relationship with a lot of the players on the Jets last year this might not be an issue. I believe he looked at the situation hoping to add value to the camp and as an opportunity to help his rookies get closer together. Traveling a great way to bond with your teammates because you have a lot of time and you're just getting to know one another so you can't help but get closer.
I'm sure Mangini is looking at this with some disappointment having believed he was thinking outside the box. Instead the media is so dry this off season they're turning him into a villain.
| powered by TheSeats.com |
Revis vs. Moss and Fortenbaugh...
Henne helps out, but Williams...
The NFP's Matt Bowen picks every...
Could this mark the end of the...
Bowen and Rosenberg discuss the...
Jun 02, 2009
04:23 PM
Pretty valid points here Matt...
Mangini is on a massive power trip and as a rookie that hasn't even put on a pair of NFL shoulder pads you might want to shut up and just do whatever you can to make the squad.