February 19, 2015 - Tony Villiotti
Quarterback trends
It is an inarguable fact that quarterback is the most important playing position on the field. This year’s playoff participants reinforce that notion. With the exception of the Cardinals, who were missing Carson Palmer due to injury, each of the 12 playoff teams had a quarterback that is solidly entrenched as a starter.
This article reviews current starting quarterbacks and determines where they came from, how soon they came starters and other relevant characteristics. The article also discusses trends that may affect a team trying to fill a need at the position.
As a first step, teams were grouped into categories based on my humble opinion of the ability of their starting quarterback. The following table reflects that categorization.
This table indicates that there are eight teams with quarterback issues. This includes the Bears (and Jay Cutler), a designation with which some might not agree. A more detailed summary of each team’s situation is on the final page of this article.
History tells us that the draft is the principal avenue for acquiring a quarterback. The current situation is no different with 22 of the 32 starters coming to their teams via the draft. If the draft day trade between the Chargers and the Giants is re-characterized as Manning and Rivers coming through the draft to their respective teams, which is in essence what happened, that number grows to 24 starters. Excluding that trade the remaining eight starters came to their current team as follows:
- Three players (Jay Cutler, Carson Palmer, Alex Smith) came via trade
- Cutler was expensive and came to the Bears along with a 5th round choice for two 1st round selections, a 3rd round pick and Kyle Orton
- Palmer was a bargain and came from the Raiders for a late round pick and an exchange of late round selections
- Smith went from the 49ers for 2nd and 3rd round selections
- One player (Tony Romo) was an undrafted free agent
- Two players (Drew Brees and Peyton Manning) came to their team via the free agent route, being available largely due to injury
- Two players (Brian Hoyer and Ryan Fitzpatrick) were journeymen free agents
- Aaron Rodgers sat behind Brett Favre for three seasons
- Philip Rivers spent two years behind Drew Brees
- Carson Palmer sat behind Jon Kitna for a year before moving up
- Tony Romo understudied Drew Bledsoe and Vinny Testaverde
- Drew Brees waited his turn behind Doug Flutie