CB Jimmy Smith is an intriguing prospect and NFL scouts I talk to have him all over the board. Size and speed at the position, but some character concerns that need to be factored into his overall evaluation. Let’s look at what you get from the former Colorado standout and decide if he deserves a first round grade.
ICONSmith has the talent and size that could produce a first-round grade.
- Can play press-man. Sounds too simple for a CB, but there are multiple prospects at the position that will come into the league and struggle at the line of scrimmage with veteran talent at WR. Talked about the size above (6-2, 211) and Smith also has the length to re-route WRs at the next level. That is a big positive when I look at CBs, because the NFL needs prospects that can play blitz coverage.
- Smith has NFL speed. Ran in the mid 4.4’s at the combine in Indianapolis. That sells in the NFL when CBs are asked to align in a press look, turn their hips and get down the field on the 9 (fade) and 8 (post). Plus, when you can carry 210-plus on your frame and still run a sub 4.5 in the 40, the NFL is going to like what they see. As we have talked about before, CB is a stopwatch position.
- Overall athletic ability. Although he can play inconsistent football at times, with Smith you get a prospect that can win matchups. He will play outside of the numbers, but I also see talent that can match up with a TE removed from the core of the formation. Isn't the most sound tackler, but in the right system he can set the edge of the defense. Plus, he will have to tackle if he wants to see the field in the NFL. That's part of the job.
- The character concerns. Hard to find a scout that doesn’t talk character with Smith. What you have to decide as an NFL coach or GM is how those issues translate to the football field. Do your homework and see if he is a fit on your squad before you take him off of the board--and weigh the talent into the equation.
- Only had three interceptions during his career at Colorado. Yes, you can throw away from top tier talent in the secondary in college football. But with no picks as a senior, you have to wonder about his ability to make game changing plays in the NFL. Will he develop into a playmaker? You need that with an investment into a first-round corner.
- Footwork can get sloppy—especially when he is asked to play from an off-man alignment. Any DB that his size will struggle to get in and out breaks, but this can be coached. Plus, from my perspective, top college players can get away with poor technique because they can make up for up with athletic ability. Not on Sundays. No question that technique is developed for all rookies at the NFL level, but don’t think you are getting a completely polished CB with Smith. He needs work.
Where do I grade him?
I look at LSU’s Patrick Peterson, Nebraska’s Prince Amukamara and Miami’s Brandon Harris as the first three corners to come off of the board in the first round. After that, I do think the discussion turns to Smith and Utah State’s Curtis Marsh. Character concerns are something to be talked about during the draft prep of NFL teams, but the overall talent, athletic ability and size are just too much for me to pass up with Smith. I would give him a late first-round grade--and if he slips into the second you are getting some value.
Follow me on Twitter: MattBowen41
OCT 31 Joel Corry
Will DeMarco Murray set the single season rushing record? Will an 8-8 mark win the NFC South? Let’s take a look.
OCT 31 Seth Schwartz
Despite having scouts at every game, James Harris wasn't a lock to be drafted.
OCT 30 Seth Schwartz
From the NFL to the CFL to the WFL and the USFL, Johnnie Walton's career was one for the ages.
OCT 28 Jeff Fedotin
Hated on by fans, San Diego’s quarterback is having an MVP-caliber year.